News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cinematography of "Andor" by fettel on Sunday June 01, 2025 @10:24AM (#44151106)
I'm a lifelong Star Wars fan, fell in love as a young kid. I remember being in 8th grade and being so excited for the prequels, and then walking out of the theater after Ep. 1 and feeling like something was just... wrong. I knew that it was junk, and not the Star Wars I fell in love with.

And from there it was pretty much further and further downhill, with occasional glimpses of hope that were quickly dashed. I tried to watch a couple more entries after the prequels, but I finally gave up and wrote it off. I've missed almost the entire last 10 years of content.

A buddy at work finally convinced me to watch Andor, and I'm so grateful he did. It is superb. I read a reddit comment that said, "This is the show that made me feel ok to be a Star Wars fan again," and I can't agree more. In a lot of ways it still feels different from Star Wars. It's hard to explain because it's in the same universe, and has similar themes (which is why it doesn't feel totally out of place), but the tone is different. It's not about Jedi knights on a mission from destiny. It's about ordinary people making decisions, and choosing hope, in the face of the oppressive might of the Empire. But god is it good. Excellent writing, great acting, suspense, intrigue, nuance, and powerful emotional scenes (that are earned by proper story buildup).

So all of that is to say, it might not be exactly what you expect, and it won't simply be "Star Wars, again," but yes you should absolutely watch it. It's a fine work of art.

Re:Cinematography of "Andor" by MangoToupe on Sunday June 01, 2025 @10:47AM (#44151277)
I actually greatly prefer the prequels to the original trilogy. I suspect it has to do with the fact that I was a child when episode 1 came out and I was still a child when the prequels concluded.

A big part of the problem is that these movies were written, basically, for 12-year old boys. You're not going to be able to get that spark back as an adult, and it's not easy to make a movie that appeals so strongly to both demographics. And much like wu-tang, star wars (and other fun stories) is for the children. Andor is at least more adult-oriented, I think.

So, do I like the new movies? No, I literally slept through the last two they were so boring, and I found the lack of coherent plot baffling. And yes, it does make me a little sad. But seeing little girls dressed up like Rey, I'm reminded that there are better things for me to care about.

Re:Cinematography of "Andor" by emblo on Sunday June 01, 2025 @11:56AM (#44151790)
I agree with most of what you're saying—that much of it is driven by nostalgia, and it's not worth getting super worked up about these things, and it's fine for people to like whatever they like—but if you do want to get into a discussion about art and the relative merits of these shows, there are good arguments that the originals executed on things like character and plot that the prequels just didn't. Red Letter Media did the best review series on why exactly the prequels felt so unsatisfying to so many people, and it's more than just preference and has to do with blunders in fundamental aspects of storytelling. All of that said it's totally fine for people to like them, and you're right that there are better things to fret over.
Re:Cinematography of "Andor" by MangoToupe on Sunday June 01, 2025 @02:53PM (#44152967)
Oh yea, critiquing movies is fun as hell, and with a franchise like star wars there's basically endless opportunity for it. I basically think Phantom Menace gets way too much critique, Clone Wars/A New Hope/Return of the Jedi don't get enough. Empire Strikes Back is really good, and whatever the third movie is was just kind of bland and depressing(it has some of the best action sequences of the series, but Padmé should have featured more strongly before dying offscreen.)

But there's a reason why the star wars fandom has such a stank reputation, and it's 100% because adult men care way too much about something meant for children to a quite creepy extent. Two things immediately come to mind: 1) the explicit and physical sexualization of Leia, which I understand but definitely don't think was necessary in retrospect (at least not so ham-handedly), and 2) the abuse of the guy who did the Jar Jar Binks voice acting. It's not his fault Lucas wrote the character as a moronic alien speaking patois. I wasn't aware of the abuse until long after it was over, but I adored jar jar binks as an eight year old boy and didn't understand why he was thereafter sidelined. This makes me also question whether criticisms by adults of the new content is a reflection of what we actually loved growing up. Could a character as weird as Yoda make it into a film now without catering much stronger to people eager to deconstruct him into eg orientalist stereotypes? Would Luke really be allowed to kiss his sister? Would Han Solo be allowed to shoot first, really?

Even the sexualization of Leia—look I'm into pulp fiction, I understand what shallow sexual stereotypes can deliver in terms of entertainment, it wasn't and still isn't crazy. You can see the same phenomenon in the current explosion of mass-published erotica ("romance"). But the stories I've heard about what Fisher was subjected to make me look at the fandom with pretty severe prejudice. It makes nerds look bad, and I also think the success of Indiana Jones shows that this wasn't necessary. It's also not the easiest thing to explain to a child or teenager who grasps something of the power dynamic between Jabba the Hutt and Leia but doesn't have the social knowledge or, frankly, cynicism to make the sense of it we do as adults.

Re:Cinematography of "Andor" by iamacyborg on Sunday June 01, 2025 @05:38PM (#44153928)
> the abuse of the guy who did the Jar Jar Binks voice acting. It's not his fault Lucas wrote the character as a moronic alien speaking patois.

Season 2 of the ILM documentary on D+ goes into this, it’s a really fascinating documentary for folks into special effects and/or star wars.

Re:Cinematography of "Andor" by Karrot_Kream on Sunday June 01, 2025 @02:53PM (#44152972)
I enjoyed the Red Letter Media series but felt it was unfair on the Prequels (which is fine, RLM is still a great series.) I ended up watching the OT a bit after Episode 2 and found them to be just as campy and flaw filled as the Prequels just in different places. But this has been litigated to death on the net since Usenet days so I'm not sure if we're gonna break new ground here (:
Re:Cinematography of "Andor" by ghaff on Sunday June 01, 2025 @11:10AM (#44151462)
I think it's probably even truer of TV series than films that you can't really go home again. But then I'm probably forgetting various Disney and other films that I probably loved as a kid that I'd find it torture to sit through today.
Re:Cinematography of "Andor" by MangoToupe on Sunday June 01, 2025 @03:12PM (#44153093)
Some stuff this is true with, but other stuff can age better. I loved MASH as a kid (huge props to the writers for pulling that off), but it's side-splitting as an adult.
Re:Cinematography of "Andor" by ghaff on Sunday June 01, 2025 @04:14PM (#44153481)
Certainly one of the great series. I think a lot of 60s sitcoms probably age less well.
Re:Cinematography of "Andor" by jimbokun on Sunday June 01, 2025 @11:30PM (#44155622)
Just FYI, MASH was 70s into early 80s, not 60s.
Re:Cinematography of "Andor" by ghaff on Monday June 02, 2025 @07:32AM (#44157726)
Very aware of that. And probably 70s hold up better than 60s but with a little bit of research could probably come up with cringeworthy 70s and 80s examples to (of which MASH is certainly not one).
Re:Cinematography of "Andor" by rockemsockem on Sunday June 01, 2025 @05:29PM (#44153870)
IDK, I feel like good kids movies tend to stay good into adulthood. Presumably you wouldn't feel like it's torture to sit through something like the Lion King (the original of course) as an adult? Like I'm not saying they're amazing movies, but I feel like good kids movies aren't painful for adults to watch. You can still have good writing, it just has to be something a kid can follow.
Re:Cinematography of "Andor" by ghaff on Sunday June 01, 2025 @05:37PM (#44153919)
Sophisticated animation can play at multiple levels. Certainly a lot of Disney and Pixar (OK now Disney). Warner Brothers cartoons.
Re:Cinematography of "Andor" by themadturk on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @06:14PM (#44175367)
A New Hope came out between my junior and senior years in college, and I was totally blown away (as I had been ten years earlier with 2001: A Space Odyssey). When my youngest son told me the prequel trilogy was his favorite Star Wars I couldn't believe it, but he pointed out that it was the Star Wars he was raised with, and saw for the first time in the theater; it was formative for him. My oldest son first really saw Star Wars when the Special Editions hit theaters, so he comes somewhere in between his younger brother and me.

I've never given up on Star Wars, though obviously there's little good to be said about the sequel trilogy and much of the Disney output. It took me a long time to even see Rogue 1, but I recognized it was something special, and Andor even moreso. (Though I will admit I like eps. 2 and 3 of the prequel trilogy more than I did at first.)

Re:Cinematography of "Andor" by lawgimenez on Sunday June 01, 2025 @10:38AM (#44151200)
As someone who’s starting reading non-jedi Star Wars books, I realized that Jedis are just a splash in the ocean. There’s Thrawn universe, Battlefront, Rebel era, X-wings, Bad Batch, too many to mention.
Re:Cinematography of "Andor" by mopenstein on Sunday June 01, 2025 @02:54PM (#44152977)
This can't be true. I'm reading all these positive accolades for Andor in this thread and there's no way I'm watching it.

Star Wars after Jedi is garbage. Lucas got me with those awful prequels and Disney got me with the first 2 new movies. I will never watch another Star Wars anything outside of the original 3 movies.

Either you never really abandon your Star Wars fandom or you're lying. There can be no other choice.

One cannot be shat upon by corporate hucksters that much and still think, "okay. I'll give 'em one more chance to shit in my eyes and ears"

Is just not possible.

Re:Cinematography of "Andor" by dbalatero on Sunday June 01, 2025 @03:34PM (#44153242)
Lol ok calm down. I agree with your quality assessment broadly, but I just finished Andor and it's excellent.
Re:Cinematography of "Andor" by jefurii on Monday June 02, 2025 @02:36PM (#44161692)
I had the same reaction to you seeing Ep. 1 for the first time, but I've come to respect the prequels. Not for their acting certainly, but for the way Lucas' scifi retelling of Roman history is so relevant to our current moment. Clone Wars and Rebels both start out pretty childish I think by the end they're nearly as gritty and serious as Andor.

Update: Clone Wars especially benefits from finding a good best-of episode guide to help move the story along.