Nobody's saying perfection is 100% required, but there are ideals and we should aim for them and design with principle. One of those principals should be quality error messages.
Hell, the rust compiler itself is a great case study for how improving error messages for users massively helps with adoption and quality of life. It's pretty rare that you hit an internal compiler error (ICE) too which is nice.
But yes, this does require that people care about diagnostics to begin with. I don't think that's worth forcing; most of us develop this instinct through frustration at dealing with the fallout of someone not caring.
(And FWIW I find the combination of explicitly-structured Results that are manually passed up the stack with RAII to be a very, very sweet spot for development velocity, and also easy to teach. I very much prefer this to both exceptions and go's approach.)
We all have moments when we're developing software and haven't fully developed the domain. Not requiring exhaustive error handling during this process is a massive help. Obviously, fully enumerated errors are good, and catering diagnostics to the users is even better. But there's more to software than shipping perfect code.