News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We are not github and that's perfectly fine by lambda on Tuesday August 21, 2012 @12:15PM (#4413351)
Hmm. I decided to take a look at the commercial licenses on Binpress, and this caught my eye:

    2.4 Including the Right to Create Derivative Works: 
    Licensee may create derivative works based on 
    Software, including amending Software’s source 
    code, modifying it, integrating it into a larger 
    work or removing portions of Software, as long as 
    no distribution of the derivative works is made
Now, a lot of the components on Binpress are things like Objective-C classes for use in iOS. But linking to such a class creates a derivative work, and it sounds like you are not then allowed to distribute your derivative work, which would make it rather useless.

Given section 2.1, it sounds like the license is intended to be used only for server-side code, not anything that will be distributed to end users.

    2.1 Limited: Licensee may use Software for the purpose of:
      2.1.1 Running Software on Licensee’s Website[s] and Server[s];
      2.1.2 Allowing 3rd Parties to run Software on Licensee’s Website[s] and 
        Server[s];
      2.1.3 Publishing Software’s output to Licensee and 3rd Parties;
      2.1.4 Distribute verbatim copies of Software’s output (including compiled 
        binaries);
      2.1.5 Modify Software to suit Licensee’s needs and specifications.
But a lot of these components are client side-components. There is either something wrong with their license, or something wrong with their curation, if they are trying to license client-side code with a license that seems to only make sense for server-side code.

There seem to be lots of other problems with the licensing, too; the license summaries will say things like "Can be distributed in 5 projects" but the actual license itself never mentions the number 5 at all (example: http://www.binpress.com/license/read/id/1225/app/1063). Or the "developers license" will say that it's "Sublicensable", but not define what that means or what restrictions there are.

Given that it seems that the core reason for Binpress to exist is to make it easy to commercially license small software components, the fact that the licenses make no sense does not make me feel very comfortable about using it.

Re:We are not github and that's perfectly fine by pytrin on Tuesday August 21, 2012 @05:08PM (#4414791)
We have a page that details the differences between the licenses type - http://www.binpress.com/content/licenses

We worked with a copyright lawyer to build those licenses, we didn't just made arbitrary decisions. I assure they are all useful in the context that they claim to be.

Re:We are not github and that's perfectly fine by lambda on Friday August 24, 2012 @02:10PM (#4428824)
You didn't really respond to any of my points. I even linked to an example of a non-sensical license; a license that uses server-side language client side code, and which has things in its summary that are completely missing from the license.

You may have had your licenses reviewed by a lawyer, but that doesn't mean that the correct license is being applied to the correct product, or that there are no bugs in your license summary system.