Yeah, significantly before the '70s, unless you're specifically talkin' about robotic automation. Folks been automating human labor with automated machinery of various kinds for quite a long time before that.
AI will probably make music free. But it is already almost free with cheap instruments, recording equipment and distribution. And even before music wasn't that expensive. You can argue that we lose value in not performing it ourselves. That is some impact, but not one that strictly replaces the other. You can choose to have society where you teach music and it will still provide value over AI.
I do realize that the idea is often not that we will have cooking robots, but that AI will change chemistry or biology to where food is something else. Still hard to say if or when that happens, and what impact it would actually have.
The issue is a lot of people (especially policymaking adjacent) have an incentive to either use a "skynet is coming" story or a "there is nothing happening" story.
The reality is it's somewhere in the middle, and plenty of white collar jobs are heavily ripe for significant reductions in headcount.
So how about service jobs? How about one of the lowest level service jobs imaginable --- taking orders at a fast food drive thru?
IBM and McDonalds spent 3 years trying to get AI to take orders at drive-thru windows.
Here are the results:
https://apnews.com/article/mcdonalds-ai-drive-thru-ibm-bebc8...
Or is it that people prefer to preorder on the phone instead and pick up?
Lots of videos on TikTok illustrate the problem.
https://www.businessinsider.com/tiktokers-show-failures-with...
Would they do significantly better with a model like Claude 4 than I’m guessing something worse than GPT3.5?
You would think so --- but well financed tests in the real world suggest otherwise.
If that doesn't sum up AI hype and apologia then I don't know what does.
Much like how when you go to one of these places >>right now<< you just walk up to a kiosk, input your order, pay, then collect your order at the desk.
Couple more years and we'll rediscover that vending machines exist.
"a Taco Bell employee is still always listening on the other end of the ordering system with the ability to intervene"
That's expecting a lot from something that still struggles to count letters in words or take orders at a fast food drive thru.
You're expecting quite a bit more if you think that here in 2025 we're at the end state of AI development.
[1] Logic, Optimization, and Constraint Programming: A Fruitful Collaboration - John Hooker - CMU (2023) [video]:
https://www.youtube.com/live/TknN8fCQvRk
[2] "We Really Don't Know How to Compute!" - Gerald Sussman - MIT (2011) [video]:
https://youtube.com/watch?v=HB5TrK7A4pI
[3] Google OR-Tools:
https://developers.google.com/optimization
[4] MiniZinc:
Take a tour of a modern auto assembly line and if you're like me, you'll be shocked by 2 things --- how few people are involved and the lack of lights (robots don't need them).
At the Hyundai factory in Mobile Alabama, only about 24 hours of human labor goes into building each car.
At an average rate of about $30 per hour, less than $1000 of human labor goes into each new car.
This doesn't leave a lot of room for AI to have a major impact.