News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: playin' the stocks game by frisco on Monday January 19, 2009 @09:09PM (#441227)
I'm saying that "practice" doesn't affect your preparedness for something that's either intrinsically random (and I mean true-random), or affected by knowledge you don't have but others with tons of capital will. You can fool yourself into thinking you're better prepared, but you're not.

"Getting good" in fantasy stocks is the equivalent of flipping a coin a hundred times, and getting some heads streaks towards the end.

Re:Ask HN: playin' the stocks game by jwilliams on Monday January 19, 2009 @09:30PM (#441240)
"Getting good" in fantasy stocks is the equivalent of flipping a coin a hundred times, and getting some heads streaks towards the end.

So using real money instead mitigates this random process in some way? That doesn't follow.

I'm not going to get into your characterisation of the market. If you believe it random, then I'll let that influence your own investing... However, investing is still has a lot of technical aspects, and practice does improve your understanding of this.

Re:Ask HN: playin' the stocks game by frisco on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @06:18AM (#441615)
Of course real money doesn't "mitigate the random process in some way." You're just more likely to switch to real money if you seem to be doing well as opposed to poorly, and I'm saying that the appearance of doing well is misplaced.