Re:Apple Is Not The Most Valuable Company In The History Of ...
by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday August 21, 2012 @06:09AM
(#4412020)
Most companies don't trade at book value because net asset value is a bad measure of market value. Getting a mark-to-market assessment on a firm's entire balance sheet is very expensive and still resorts to estimating market value rather than directly sampling it.
One could do equity value + discounted payouts - discounted invested capital. This includes payments on debt and possibly taxes.
This measure would not be a "value" in an economic sense as valuation is in present terms, incorporating future potential and using the past only to inform assumptions. This measure catalogs a company's time-integrated capital productivity. This could inform a valuation, but taking an extreme case, it would value dearly a shell company that just paid its assets out in a dividend.
With the subjectivity complexities like cross-border activity or M&A introduce the exercise has little value beyond the pedagogical.
One could do equity value + discounted payouts - discounted invested capital. This includes payments on debt and possibly taxes.
This measure would not be a "value" in an economic sense as valuation is in present terms, incorporating future potential and using the past only to inform assumptions. This measure catalogs a company's time-integrated capital productivity. This could inform a valuation, but taking an extreme case, it would value dearly a shell company that just paid its assets out in a dividend.
With the subjectivity complexities like cross-border activity or M&A introduce the exercise has little value beyond the pedagogical.