Re:Starship Flight 9 launches successfully, booster explodes...
by timschmidt on Wednesday May 28, 2025 @11:45AM
(#44117263)
N1 would have worked eventually with enough effort. The larger problem is that Korolev died and his deputy was far less politically capable.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Starship Flight 9 launches successfully, booster explodes...
by preisschild on Friday May 30, 2025 @04:49AM
(#44134228)
Its questionable if it would have ever worked
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/apollo-moon-khrus...
> Korolev was not a scientist, not a designer: he was a brilliant manager. Korolev's problem was his mentality. His intent was to somehow use the launcher he had. [The launcher was called N1]. It was designed in 1958 for a different purpose and with a limited payload of about 70 tons.] His philosophy was, let's not work by stages [as is usual in spacecraft design], but let's assemble everything and then try it. And at last it will work. There were several attempts and failures with Lunnik [a series of unmanned Soviet moon probes]. Sending man to the moon is too complicated, too complex for such an approach. I think it was doomed from the very beginning.