Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem...
by strogonoff on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @03:53AM
(#44104814)
Just call it “committing bad code”. LLM autocomplete aside, I don’t see how reviewing own code can happen without either a split personality, or putting enough time that you completely forgot what exactly you were doing and have fresh eyes and mind.
If person A committed code that looks bad to person B, it just means person A commits bad code by the standard of person B, not that person A “does not review own code”.
Maybe it’s a subjective difference, same as you could call someone “rude” or you could say the same person “didn’t think before saying”.
Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem...
by solaire_oa on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @11:16AM
(#44107789)
Person A as can commit atrocious code all day, that's fine, but they still need to proofread their MR/PR and fix the outstanding issues. The only way to see outstanding issues is by reviewing the MR/PR. Good writers proofread their documents.
Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem...
by strogonoff on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @12:03PM
(#44108253)
I just don’t see reading your own stuff as a different activity from writing. Generally, there is the author, and proofreader is a dedicated role.
If you need an example, it's easy to add a debugging/logging statement like `console.log`, but if the coder committed and submitted the log statement, then they clearly didn't review the code at all, and there are probably much bigger code issues at stake. This is a problem even without LLMs.