Re:Ask HN: Anyone struggling to get value out of coding LLMs?
by cassianoleal on Monday May 26, 2025 @05:52PM
(#44102018)
> the reality is that a lot of development work doesn't necessarily rely on the strong engineering methodology (e.g. measurement, material properties, tolerances, modelling, etc.)
It's probably true that a lot of development work doesn't rely on those. It's probably also true that the work other kinds of engineers do also don't.
That said, when engineering software systems, those are very important. Measurement: resource sizing, observability; tolerances: backoffs, back pressure, queues, topics, buffers; modelling: types, syntax, data analytics...
There's a whole class of developers out there that are not aware or very good at those. And that's fine. There's a place for them in the market. You don't need an engineer to work on your floor joists or your plumbing. Sure you can have one, but you can also hire a builder or DIY it all yourself.
It's probably true that a lot of development work doesn't rely on those. It's probably also true that the work other kinds of engineers do also don't.
That said, when engineering software systems, those are very important. Measurement: resource sizing, observability; tolerances: backoffs, back pressure, queues, topics, buffers; modelling: types, syntax, data analytics...
There's a whole class of developers out there that are not aware or very good at those. And that's fine. There's a place for them in the market. You don't need an engineer to work on your floor joists or your plumbing. Sure you can have one, but you can also hire a builder or DIY it all yourself.