> ... the amount of data included in their plans before insane pricing kicks in is frequently still measured in megabytes.
Mobile data plans are a joke in my country[1].
1. http://blog.binarybalance.com.au/2012/05/12/internet-anemia-...
It's fair to question how much developers should concern themselves with external costs for using their service.
Do we have a responsibility to design for data caps to prevent unnecessary charges? Do we have a responsibility to do the opposite, as an industry exerting pressure on carriers to increase cap levels? Somewhere in between?
Honestly, I don't know. I'm inclined to design for a user's reality rather than a principle, but that "in the real world" thinking allowed the web to be dominated by "best viewed in IE6" sites.
I wouldn't go so far as to say we have a solemn duty to always take such issues into account. But as a designer/developer, it is certainly something I myself would spare a thought for because - putting on my consumer hat - I am directly affected by the problem of shitty data plans at present and I'd like to think it's something that designers/developers would be aware of, regardless of whether they then make an informed choice one way or the other.
> Do we have a responsibility to do the opposite, as an industry exerting pressure on carriers to increase cap levels?
I'd like to think this would work. But I really just can't see it.
I too would be leaning towards designing for ther reality. But it seems we're in the time of 'case by case basis' on this issue. I don't think there's a single correct answer.
Latency is the bottleneck you should tackle first when addressing mobile performance, not asset size - the world has already spent a lot of time optimizing asset size for web delivery. But phones are bad at handling lots of requests. Serving a single high-resolution graphic will have significantly less impact on page rendering speed (and even more important, perceived rendering speed) than a handful of smaller assets which add up to the same size.
For a real world example, a mobile phone can download and render a single large photo faster than the gaggle of javascript, css, and social network share icons typically presented next to it.
Many have examined and written about this. Here's a blog article that Google ranks on the subject: http://www.webperformancetoday.com/2012/04/02/mobile-versus-...