Pinochet was protected from extradition because he, unlike Assange, was a head of state and enjoyed a supposed immunity from prosecution as a result.
I'm sure it was also quite helpful that he was friendly with various high ranking British politicians, meeting Thatcher several times, and helping them with a little war they had in the South Atlantic.
Re:Legal myths about the Assange extradition
by tomjen3 on Monday August 20, 2012 @03:59PM
(#4409497)
I believe the English law system is based on common law, meaning that cases stack and can use precedents from earlier cases.
Re:Legal myths about the Assange extradition
by tptacek on Monday August 20, 2012 @04:12PM
(#4409550)
The precedent that you are referring to here is what? That Assange, as a foreign head of state, is immune to extradition?
Re:Legal myths about the Assange extradition
by brudgers on Monday August 20, 2012 @04:38PM
(#4409667)
I believe the precedent being cited is that the general welfare may be more important than black letter law.
Re:Legal myths about the Assange extradition
by tptacek on Monday August 20, 2012 @04:51PM
(#4409737)
I'm pretty sure that's not a precedent set by the failure to extradite Pinochet, who was a genocidal tyrant.
Re:Legal myths about the Assange extradition
by rprasad on Monday August 20, 2012 @06:32PM
(#4410133)
So does American law, but you are clearly misunderstanding what "precedent" means.
Judicial decisions operate as precedent. Executive decisions do not. A judicial decision that Pinochet could not be extradited would be precedent; a decision not to extradite him would not be. The distinction is that the actual decision to extradite or not is based on both circumstances unique to the case and to the particular views of the administration making the decision.
In fact, justice demands the opposite. Pinochet was protected from extradition because he, unlike Assange, was a head of state and enjoyed a supposed immunity from prosecution as a result. The hesitation to force Pinochet to face due process for his (very compellingly) alleged crimes is a travesty. In recognizing that a travesty occurred, we don't just award points to one state and accord demerits to another: we also seek to avoid the recurrence of that travesty in the future.