News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There was a time when the US government built homes for w... by catigula on Sunday May 25, 2025 @10:08AM (#44087954)
I'm just confused as to why the US population needed to grow by almost 100 million since I was born without any sort of infrastructure undertaking to sustain that massive immigration. My local community is terrifically swollen with people and everything built for 1/3rd the population is now crumbling under that weight.
Re:There was a time when the US government built homes for w... by ajross on Sunday May 25, 2025 @10:19AM (#44088034)
Most of suburban America wasn't built yet when you were born. I don't understand this point at all. You don't think sprawl counts as infrastructure? It may not be the housing you (or I) personally think should have been built, but it's absolutely housing. And it was built in great quantity at great cost, and even turned out to be great investments. And it came with schools and strip malls and freeway interchanges and substations to connect it all. Living in the modern US is paradise in almost all quantifiable ways.

It's also, it needs be said, wasn't built to support (sigh[1]) "massive immigration". You can find a few H1B holders peppered around, but the sprawl is for the middle class, 100%.

[1] Seriously, why must everything become a callout to right wing grievance politics these days?

Re:There was a time when the US government built homes for w... by catigula on Sunday May 25, 2025 @10:26AM (#44088075)
I think you trying to transmute this to polemic weakens the points you've attempted to make.

Obviously we disagree but the point I feel most compelled to push back against is your assertion that "living in the modern US is paradise in almost all quantifiable ways".

This is such a problematic statement that clearly labors heavily under the burden of its own premise. A crude metric is quite telling: suicide has trended upwards in the past 20 years. I presume if the data went back further the picture would be more stark.

Living in a time with gizmos and gadgets and economic plenty that is weakly distributed and calling that "paradise" is very insulting to people's lived experiences and part of the reason I think the economic message of the politics you represent alienates average folks.

Based on your posts it seems like you've been a wealthy developer for decades and likely have employed, or employ, cheap labor. Kind of feels like a rugpull, Ross.

Personally, I've managed many teams with cheap foreign developers, I'm just straight about it.

Also, when do you think I was born? You think the US hadn't been built in 1982? Absurd claims all around.

Re:There was a time when the US government built homes for w... by jpc0 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @10:40AM (#44088182)
I think the situation is likely significantly more nuanced than either of your points of view allows.

Suicide and basic needs being met is likely not highly correlated. On the other side suicide stats likely don’t include dependency related death, alcoholism can be a coping mechanism, if you didn’t commit suicide but instead murdered your liver and died early is that really a different statistic in your assessment?

The only way you can measure is access to basic needs, housing, shelter, medical care, nutrition. A century ago those things were significantly lower for the average person vs now. Could the world be in a better situation? Very likely yes, but is could also be much worse.

If you want to significantly change things then better, advocate for more social workers and to make sure the social welfare system works through them. They are in my experience very good at sussing out whether someone is a leech to society and is just looking for a handout of someone who is truly in need.

Advocate for adequate housing, more suburbs doesn’t help low-middle class people, you need more dense housing close to infrastructure or workplaces.

Re:There was a time when the US government built homes for w... by catigula on Sunday May 25, 2025 @10:44AM (#44088205)
I respect your thoughts here because I think they come from a good place and that you want to help people.

I just don't know how to express to you how philosophically naive I think the kind of utilitarian assertion you've made is.

We can easily construct a thought experiment world that you and I would both agree is a living hellscape where all human needs were simultaneously being met. Most horror science fiction is predicated on those premises.

Re:There was a time when the US government built homes for w... by jpc0 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @11:02AM (#44088349)
I don’t disagree, the world is much much more nuanced than a black or white take can express.

I just think we don’t need to debate this, things are better than a century ago but they are still not great.

Quality of life isn’t solely based on basic needs alone, but for the vast majority of people those basic needs are now met when they weren’t before. That doesn’t mean we get to say, “That’s good enough let’s pack up” there’s still a lot of work to do.

Re:There was a time when the US government built homes for w... by catigula on Sunday May 25, 2025 @11:06AM (#44088372)
I think I probably disagree.

Fundamentally the question to me becomes "what is the meaning of life" and I don't actually think the answer is even "to be extremely comfortable".

This is my core disagreement with tech enthusiasts (specifically AI) people. It's just a naive way of understanding the human organism.

(You know, it occurs to me that most Americans aren't even extremely comfortable because they live in comfort with a massive amount of real or perceived precarity.)

Re:There was a time when the US government built homes for w... by jpc0 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @11:27AM (#44088503)
I do want to see your point of view but I’m not seeing it clearly right now.

I can tell you my point of view is that we aren’t even sure what we should do. I know reasonably well how to solve the basic needs, in my experience that doesn’t mean you are going to be happy, I was the unhappiest in my life when I had the most I’ve had. Well maybe the second unhappiest, there was a point in my life I will never want to go back to, but I don’t think I will.

When everything was going well, I needed nothing, I was achieving all my life goals, I fought through the worst depression, I had to seek medical help.

Re:There was a time when the US government built homes for w... by sokoloff on Sunday May 25, 2025 @10:32AM (#44088113)
I looked for older suicide rate data and it doesn’t support what I think is your view above.

At the turn of the previous century, suicide rates were markedly higher than today, even though today is worse than 20 years ago.

https://jabberwocking.com/raw-data-us-suicide-rates-since-19...

Re:There was a time when the US government built homes for w... by catigula on Sunday May 25, 2025 @10:35AM (#44088139)
I'm not sure what point you think is being made but your own chart shows suicide exploding during the exact timeline we're discussing.

It's probably not causative, as that would be quite silly, but economic plenty for extremely wealthy people caused by a massive influx of cheap labor is clearly not a net boon on this metric.

The US made its bones well before this insane population explosion we only very recently had.

(Yes, we've had large amounts of immigration before. We also built infrastructure and were vastly less developed).

Re:There was a time when the US government built homes for w... by sokoloff on Sunday May 25, 2025 @10:45AM (#44088217)
It shows it increasing after a notably low period. It’s increased back to a level similar to 1950, which are both dramatically lower than 1900-1940. What’s the “right” reference point? Was 2000 an anomaly while today’s rate is a mere reversion to the mean? Or a reversion to a measure which is still better than the 100-year mean?
Re:There was a time when the US government built homes for w... by catigula on Sunday May 25, 2025 @10:50AM (#44088251)
Putting aside my concerns about the integrity of the data, the clearly "correct" reference point is the one it takes to falsify the parent comment's claim: that this extremely brief period of gizmos, gadgets, economic plenty and mass immigration is somehow an unparalleled land of milk and honey. You could directly correlate our literal exact debate as negative evidence of his assertion.
Re:There was a time when the US government built homes for w... by sokoloff on Sunday May 25, 2025 @10:58AM (#44088318)
I assume then that you agree that the data I cited refutes your presumption here:

> A crude metric is quite telling: suicide has trended upwards in the past 20 years. I presume if the data went back further the picture would be more stark.

Re:There was a time when the US government built homes for w... by catigula on Sunday May 25, 2025 @11:03AM (#44088356)
No, not really.

1. The data going back 70 years, which is 50 years more than 20, show that suicide has sharply risen.

2. The integrity of data much older than that is substantially in question.

Re:There was a time when the US government built homes for w... by sokoloff on Sunday May 25, 2025 @11:18AM (#44088447)
Allow me to literally quote from the article I linked:

> After two decades of slowly rising, the US suicide rate has stabilized over the past few years. It is now at the same level as the 1950s.

Re:There was a time when the US government built homes for w... by sdenton4 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @11:06AM (#44088373)
The y axis on the chart starts at 10, not zero... It shows a rise of perhaps 40% over the last twenty years. This looks to be similar to the range of total variation since 1950, though the trajectory of the curve is worrisome.

And yeah, the rates pre-1950 were much, much higher.

Re:There was a time when the US government built homes for w... by catigula on Sunday May 25, 2025 @11:08AM (#44088380)
I'm not interested in partisan political discussions. I don't agree that Trump or anyone else can, or is even attempting to address core problems, and also think falling for that premise is silly.
Re:There was a time when the US government built homes for w... by tzs on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:09PM (#44089655)
> Most of suburban America wasn't built yet when you were born.

That doesn't sound right.

They said that the US population has grown by almost 100 million since they were born. That would put their birth year around 1989.

Some searching suggests that in 1989 about 50% of the population lived in suburban areas. That would have been about 120 million people.

It is still about 50% which is 170 million people today. That suggests that around 70% of the suburbs were already built when they were born.

Re:There was a time when the US government built homes for w... by ajross on Sunday May 25, 2025 @11:32PM (#44093721)
> That doesn't sound right.

Which is usually how these arguments go.

Are there more or fewer homeless people in the US than in 1982? There are fewer. Is the number of people per household larger or smaller than in 1982? It is smaller. Is the average home larger or smaller than in 1982? It is larger (very significantly so). Do the math. We're building housing faster than population growth. QED.

And, overwhelmingly, we're building that housing in suburban sprawl, because that's where it's cheap to build housing.

Now, there are many arguments about whether this is good or bad or whether policies could be better or worse. And I think you'd find you agree with me on more than you don't.

But statements like the above that seem to take as a prior that "massive immigration" (sigh, again) is somehow creating an infrastructure crises are simply wrong. Period. Start with correct arguments, then tune. Don't yell about one because your priors tell you it "doesn't sound right".

[dead]
Re:There was a time when the US government built homes for w... by seneca on Sunday May 25, 2025 @10:14AM (#44088000)
I may very well print this post our and frame it. Perfect distillation of modern America.
Re:There was a time when the US government built homes for w... by therealpygon on Wednesday May 28, 2025 @09:52AM (#44116053)
You believe the increase in population has been caused by “massive immigration”?

We’ve had roughly 4 million births and 2 million deaths per year since 1980. That is roughly a difference of 90 million. Additionally, when people cite immigration numbers, they frequently leave out negating numbers; the amount of people who were here temporarily, the amount of people who were deported or left voluntarily, and those who are “repeat offenders” in terms of migration that are frequently counted multiple times. So while yes, the number of immigrants as a percentage of population has increased in that time, the entire population increase is not a direct result of the roughly 10-15% they account for, which also aligns with the roughly 10-15% of the population they account for. Also, if you go back further than just when you were born, the US had roughly 14% immigrant population since 1900. Racism (in the form of nationalism/anti-immigration/etc) and nationalist changes to immigration laws reduced that number to 3% in the 20s, which has been slowly returning to the same 14% level since the 70s.

The US population growth has slowed overall since you were born, averaging a rate of 1% +/- 0.5% over that time and currently lower than when you were born. During that same time, our average infrastructure spending has grown from 300 to 600 billion a year; a 100% increase over that time compared to 1% growth in population per year.

So, given all these facts, how do you reconcile your statements that we have added 100 million due to massive immigration with no increases in infrastructure, when the facts seem to directly refute your assertions?