Re:College English majors can't read
by rahimnathwani on Friday May 23, 2025 @08:50AM
(#44072407)
I should have been more specific about what I meant :)
Your answer is reasonable but, it's entirely about the principal-agent problem.
What if you were the boss, and you were accountable only to yourself and your family?
Realistically, I would weight the two educations as roughly equal and judge on other factors.
Re:College English majors can't read
by rahimnathwani on Friday May 23, 2025 @09:49AM
(#44072878)
If I had to choose between:
A) Someone with a 4-year degree in English, from Pittsburg State (one of the two colleges in that study), and
B) Someone who just finished high school, and got a high SAT score.
Then I'd choose B. (Being a graduate of Pittsburgh State suggests an SAT score in the range 900 to 1200.)
Depends on what my incentives are on the hiring end. Many jobs default to requiring a college degree, and hiring someone without one would require a lot of extra work on my end. Also hiring a high school grad over a college grad would involve me putting my reputation on the line by implicitly vouching for them. If the high school kid can't do the job I will get blamed for the bad hire since I broke the procedures put in place to prevent such a thing from happening. I the college graduate sucks at the job, well these things happen, you did what you could.