News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tallest Wooden Wind Turbine by adwn on Friday May 23, 2025 @05:30AM (#44071310)
Your explanation raises the follow-up question, which svantana already hinted at: Why don't construction cranes use hollow tubes instead of their typical truss structures?
Re:Tallest Wooden Wind Turbine by wizardOfScience on Friday May 23, 2025 @05:36AM (#44071337)
The crane manufacturing business case is not driven by material efficiency to the same degree. It is a tool that needs to be reliable and have performance in operations. Limit the need for man hours through ease of use etc. It should also be able to take many assembly/disassembly cycles.

Thus does the amount of material not matter as much in a crane.

For wind turbine towers the material cost can be >>50% of the installed cost.

Re:Tallest Wooden Wind Turbine by majoe on Friday May 23, 2025 @12:47PM (#44074397)
Working for a crane manufacturing company. While raw material costs are maybe not that drastic, we consider material efficiency the most important metric for cost and a lot of brain power was spent to optimise the amount of steel used. There are multiple reasons for this. The ones I can think of are:

  * The margins for cranes are thin and steel is expensive.
  * Thicker steel is harder to work with, increasing manufacturing cost.
  * Each kg of dead weight may decrease the performance of your product, e.g. max. Live load. This is especially true for the jib.
  * More weight at the top of the crane may necessitate a sturdier structure below, amplifying cost even more.
  * More weight may require more ballast blocks, which are costly (especially transport)
  * More weight means higher transport costs
  * More weight means more wind area, which is the critical factor for high constructions.
Re:Tallest Wooden Wind Turbine by IsTom on Friday May 23, 2025 @05:36AM (#44071336)
Certainly makes them easier to disassemble and move elsewhere.
Re:Tallest Wooden Wind Turbine by dguest on Friday May 23, 2025 @10:50AM (#44073436)
Yeah it's pretty essential that construction equipment be pretty easy to construct and deconstruct. There are some videos [1] which are worth checking out.

[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vx5Qt7_ECEE

Re:Tallest Wooden Wind Turbine by Aldipower on Friday May 23, 2025 @06:59AM (#44071704)
Because at cranes the force is not the wind that comes from any direction, but the directed payload hanging at the crane arm. Almost all cranes I now moving also the pole around.
Re:Tallest Wooden Wind Turbine by carlosjobim on Friday May 23, 2025 @06:42AM (#44071623)
My guess: They want the wind to pass through the crane, while they want wind turbines to capture the wind.
Re:Tallest Wooden Wind Turbine by majoe on Friday May 23, 2025 @12:58PM (#44074486)
This is the answer.

Interestingly, wind/storm loads are oftentimes the limiting factor for the configuration height of a crane.

This is because, when adding another tower segment, not only the total area increases but also the wind forces. The other loads stay roughly the same

This is the reason why bottom-slewing cranes, which are commonly used for small buildings, sometimes are built with solid walls. Top-slewing cranes, which are used for high buildings, always use a steel framework.