News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: DockFlow – Switch between multiple macOS Dock la... by greatgib on Thursday May 22, 2025 @03:32PM (#44065859)
Totally wrong. First saying win9x doesn't make any sense. You can say Windowsish is some way but not less than current one.

But that being said, it is wrong because everything is possible to suit to your taste. Cinnamon itself can look like and work how you want it, Mac like, or Windows like, or totally different. But you could also switch easily to other distribution or change the desktop or task manager as you see fit.

In MacOS you are hopeless, the system itself is rigid. I had hope with Ubar to get a better experience but it is a useless crap, not by it's own fault I think because of having no possibility to improve things.

Otherwise, sure changing is always momentarily disrupting but people are really suffering from the bad ergonomic of MacOS even if they might not really realize it after decade learning of tricks to get around as much as possible of all the issues and frustration with the interface. Like needing the tool of this article to try to make the experience bearable as I said.

To me, it is like the previous decade with the former generation of Windows users saying that they had no issue with windows that was working perfectly flawlessly for them without not realizing the issues plugging a new device, the constant nagging of popup and error windows, the regular slowdown and data loss. But they were used to it. Nowadays, no one will contest anymore that Windows is really not good.

In my opinion, the ergonomic issues in MacOS are really physically painful to the point where users might have hands issues in a few years. You are constantly needed to do complex movement to go from one window to another when it should not be needed or just be a click. Like when you have things like multiple web browser windows, you have to constantly do multiple clicks or complex movement to open the list of windows in the task bar select the right one, then do again just the other window being in another position in the list, and so on. Things like reading a pdf and copying different sections in a document or form in another app is terrible having to switch constantly from one to another. There are hundreds of things like that like the impossibility totally maximize windows without being the annoying full Fullscreen, except on your taskbar, installation of apps is a joke except for devs that will install and only use brew; there are constantly people leaving meetings to go find and set the obscure mac setting to enable the camera or screen sharing that turns itself off randomly; in 8gb Mac that was the standard, Mac was silently evicting most apps once you switch, resulting in 1 or 2 seconds to go from one app to another, ...

Re:Show HN: DockFlow – Switch between multiple macOS Dock la... by cosmic_cheese on Thursday May 22, 2025 @03:44PM (#44066008)
No desktop environment is capable of full Mac-like operation. None have an application-based paradigm for example and instead all use a Windows-like window-based one instead. While it’s possible to get a global menubar on a couple, the feature is hacky at best and only works properly with a handful of apps.

Rigidity is only a problem when the broad strokes aren’t congruent with the user’s desires. This is why a lot of longtime Windows and Linux users have trouble with macOS while longtime Mac users install a couple of third party utilities and are perfectly cozy.

macOS ergonomics aren’t perfect, as they aren’t with any OS, but are perfectly functional if you know your way around. Navigation is not a problem if you’re using key shortcuts for both switching apps and windows for example and don’t have a solely window-based mental model. It’s been possible to maximize windows without fullscreen by holding down option when using the key shortcut or clicking the green button.

Permissions are a growing pain that every desktop OS will eventually need to face. The old model of every app having access to everything whenever it wishes doesn’t work in the modern era, and dealing with that is something seen even under Linux with things like Flatpak.