Re:Why Fukushima Was Preventable
by Retric on Sunday August 19, 2012 @11:33AM
(#4404256)
You can dramatically slow reactors down, but you can't actually 'shut down' because simply decay produces significant amounts of heat. So the real problem at Fukushima was the need to be able to passively cool a reactor indefinitely in that 'slow' state without human interaction and that's where they failed. Sure, if they had power and none of the connectors had failed it would have also been ok, but without long term passive safety nuclear power is not safe.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Why Fukushima Was Preventable
by jimktrains2 on Sunday August 19, 2012 @12:04PM
(#4404358)
Yes, I understand that you can't just turn them "off." It's easiest just to say that it's shut off if it's unable to do anything really.
I think you missed everything in my previous post. All new designs passively cool. You can have safe (comparative to coal and gas) nuclear power.
I should have been more clear, a lot of designs passively cool the reactor / primary loop, but they don't have long term 100% passive cooling on the secondary loop. Though a counter example would be welcome.
Re:Why Fukushima Was Preventable
by mjvandenbergh on Sunday August 19, 2012 @03:07PM
(#4404829)
No, you're right. They have a water pool that cools the secondary loop. That will need refilling after a few days, 72 hours for the ESBWR iirc.