News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dilbert creator Scott Adams says he will die soon from sa... by prepend on Monday May 19, 2025 @02:28PM (#44033072)
Some people believe in things and aren’t minmaxing their life based on what gives them the best return.

Of course, they can be wrong. But I always find it odd when people say “I don’t understand” when it seems so obvious to me. They see things as right vs wrong and want to make things right even if it hurts them.

Re:Dilbert creator Scott Adams says he will die soon from sa... by wat10000 on Monday May 19, 2025 @03:14PM (#44033665)
I don't understand believing that trans people (or whatever other belief) are a major threat, but I understand getting heavily involved in policies around trans people if one were to somehow believe that trans people are a major threat.

What I don't understand is spending your days shitposting on Twitter about it. I'm not sure if that applies to Adams, but it definitely applies to Musk and Rowling.

Re:Dilbert creator Scott Adams says he will die soon from sa... by johnp271 on Monday May 19, 2025 @05:38PM (#44035167)
I have not seen any indication that Rowling, Musk, or Adams assert that trans people are categorically a "major threat". That said, these folks do view trans people as a "major threat" to those athletes who compete in the category that once was exclusive to humans distinguished by having XX chromosomes. They believe, and rightly so in my opinion, that this athletic competition category should remain exclusive to those humans scientifically established (usually pretty obvious at birth) to have XX chromosomes.
Re:Dilbert creator Scott Adams says he will die soon from sa... by slg on Monday May 19, 2025 @06:40PM (#44035729)
>those humans scientifically established (usually pretty obvious at birth) to have XX chromosomes

It is entirely possible your heart is in the right place, but this specific comment gives it away that you haven't actually looked at this issue too closely. There are "scientifically established" reasons why this issue is a lot more complicated than the anti-trans folks always make it out to be, even if we completely ignore the existence of trans people. Look up Swyer Syndrome[1] for example.

[1] - https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/swyer-syndrom...

Re:Dilbert creator Scott Adams says he will die soon from sa... by aaaja on Monday May 19, 2025 @07:00PM (#44035853)
CAIS is a better example. Even then it's overrepresented in athletic competition compared to the general population.

Swyer syndrome isn't a condition compatible with an athletic career because of the bone weakening caused by hormone deficiency.

Re:Dilbert creator Scott Adams says he will die soon from sa... by wat10000 on Monday May 19, 2025 @06:57PM (#44035832)
The obvious indication is that they’re putting a huge amount of time and money into this issue. If they don’t think it’s a major threat then what are they even doing?
Re:Dilbert creator Scott Adams says he will die soon from sa... by romaniitedomum on Monday May 19, 2025 @06:34PM (#44035683)
> I don't understand believing that trans people (or whatever other belief) are a major threat, but I understand getting heavily involved in policies around trans people if one were to somehow believe that trans people are a major threat.

You are presenting a strawman argument, and then declaring you can't believe that others believe this. The truth is, they don't believe that.

What women like J.K Rowling argue is that women's and girl's rights are harmed by insisting that trans people be treated for all purposes as their declared gender without regard to their birth sex. They argue that women and girls by virtue of their sex need single-sex facilities where males aren't admitted, no matter how that male self-identifies. They argue that treating adolescents expressing gender confusion with puberty blockers and surgery is extremely harmful and morally wrong.

And it's clear from recent surveys and polls that clear majorities in most western countries agree. An example of this is a recent poll in the UK regarding its recent Supreme Court judgement on the interpretation of its Equality Act. [1][2]

Regardless of the position you take on this, nothing is to be gained by not engaging with what others are actually saying and arguing.

[1] https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/supreme-cour...

[2] https://www.thetimes.com/uk/politics/article/half-of-labour-...

Re:Dilbert creator Scott Adams says he will die soon from sa... by wat10000 on Monday May 19, 2025 @06:55PM (#44035817)
I’m trying to be charitable. The alternative is that these people are spending a ton of their personal time and wealth on a problem that is not a major threat, which is a much worse look for them.
Re:Dilbert creator Scott Adams says he will die soon from sa... by aaaja on Monday May 19, 2025 @07:13PM (#44035973)
Re:Dilbert creator Scott Adams says he will die soon from sa... by wat10000 on Monday May 19, 2025 @08:48PM (#44036617)
Definitely sounds like she thinks this is a major threat.
Re:Dilbert creator Scott Adams says he will die soon from sa... by prepend on Monday May 19, 2025 @09:13PM (#44036763)
Are they spending a ton of their time and wealth. Rowling has tweeted like 20 times in 5 years. It doesn’t seem like a big part of her life, just something she’s talked about.

It’s like I comment about oatmeal raisin cookies. I like them and will engage in conversation every few months or so. But it’s not a ton of my life. I don’t wake up and go to bed thinking of cookies.

Re:Dilbert creator Scott Adams says he will die soon from sa... by wat10000 on Monday May 19, 2025 @09:53PM (#44037001)
Huh? I checked her account to see how many times she’s tweeted in the past day, but I got bored and stopped after 20. And every. Single. One. Is about trans stuff.
Re:Dilbert creator Scott Adams says he will die soon from sa... by aaaja on Tuesday May 20, 2025 @04:38AM (#44039222)
No it's not. Latest tweet is a retweet about the assisted dying bill going through Parliament. Next is about women's rights to single-sex spaces in context of the recent Supreme Court ruling.

Three tweets down is a retweet about an LGB conference. The tweet before that is about her taking legal action against libellous statements.

A few more tweets down from that is something about a man who fought a polar bear off with a saucepan.

Re:Dilbert creator Scott Adams says he will die soon from sa... by wat10000 on Tuesday May 20, 2025 @07:55AM (#44040522)
I don’t see those. Given the intense pace at which she posts stuff, maybe I just didn’t go far enough.

Women’s rights to single-sex spaces and LGB conferences are definitely about trans issues. I bet the libelous statements thing is too.

Re:Dilbert creator Scott Adams says he will die soon from sa... by lupusreal on Tuesday May 20, 2025 @09:40AM (#44041539)
I think many people view it as a "four lights" situation. How many lights there are isn't really consequential, when you see four lights and you're being commanded to say there are five lights or else, you're going to have some people dig in their heels and refuse to submit no matter how much it hurts them. In fact, rich people who can insulate themselves from the hurt are in the best position to obstinately stick to their version of things.
Re:Dilbert creator Scott Adams says he will die soon from sa... by wat10000 on Tuesday May 20, 2025 @10:21AM (#44041988)
Gotta love HN. Being asked to call people what they prefer to be called is equivalent to being tortured by fascists.
Re:Dilbert creator Scott Adams says he will die soon from sa... by ToucanLoucan on Monday May 19, 2025 @02:37PM (#44033197)
That's a fair rebuttal. I guess what I don't understand is the reflexive nature to double-triple-quadruple down into stuff that's like... not even overly difficult to discern as being wrong? Like to come back to Scott Adams, he seems to have a lifelong set of issues around socializing, and is a bit racist. But like, he managed a successful career that got around those things. So why come back in his twilight years to be really racist in public, even as people asked him to not? Even has a lot of his fans asked him to not?

It's such a bizarre hill to die on.

Re:Dilbert creator Scott Adams says he will die soon from sa... by prepend on Monday May 19, 2025 @09:15PM (#44036765)
I think if you ask Scott Adam’s if he’s racist, he doesn’t think so. So the hill to die on is something to the effect of what he thinks is right and he doesn’t see that as racist.