Re:Decentralized Twitter? You just don't get it.
by volaski on Saturday August 18, 2012 @11:36PM
(#4403132)
Let's say you hosted your Diaspora or Status.net or whatever on your heroku server. You post something and it gets huge traffic and the server goes down. And this doesn't happen just for you but for lots of people on average. Who will maintain this? In this type of environment, you cannot make any assumptions on realtime delivery. That's what I mean by it's not a technology problem. You can use XMPP in Google Talk since most of the times you're doing 1:1 chat. Twitter does 1:N (where N goes up to as large as several millions), and this becomes a big deal. Does this make sense?
XMPP is performant enough for Google to use it as the IM component of Google Talk. Google Talk is instant messaging. Not "eventual messaging." Instant. Just like the centralized alternatives.
Centralized services have some pros over distributed ones -- ease of discovering other users is a big one. But you're just making an assertion that only a centralized system can pass messages back and forth fast enough to be perceived as effectively instant without providing any evidence to back that assertion up.