News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by old-gregg on Friday August 17, 2012 @10:39PM (#4400003)
Quite amusing to see the word "regime" used so casually and self-righteously. As much as you may dislike Putin, I bet he's got more popular votes than Obama did, just visit an average Russian town 50 miles outside of Moscow and ask around.

As a Russian I know first hand things aren't rosy, but they aren't so simplistic and cartoonishly evil as western media and comments on HN portray.

Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by ak217 on Friday August 17, 2012 @11:03PM (#4400061)
As a Russian, I think you're full of shit. It's not about the votes (officially, Putin got 46 million votes; Obama got 69 million). It's about the harassment, media manipulation, gutting of the judiciary, vote rigging, and now, terror.

In the long run, the terror may be something of a good thing: it may hasten Putin's demise. In the short run, he has squandered the last of the opportunities that the Soviet industrial and technological base had given him.

And it's not that he always was evil: until 2002, he legitimately did a good job of strengthening the state when it was weak and reeling from Chechnya. But then he never stopped.

Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by beambot on Friday August 17, 2012 @11:15PM (#4400089)
It's about the harassment, media manipulation, gutting of the judiciary, vote rigging, and now, terror.

I seriously couldn't tell: are you talking about Russia or the US here...?

Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by beambot on Saturday August 18, 2012 @06:09AM (#4400739)
Not sure about the downvotes... But my point stands: As an American, these seem to be common political tactics here too. If GP doesn't want to compare Putin and Obama on votes, I'd appreciate a point-by-point breakdown along these axes.
Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by justin66 on Saturday August 18, 2012 @07:12AM (#4400833)
This is a puzzling comment which makes me wonder about your perception of both the US and Russia.

Can you really imagine a punk rock band in the US getting two years in prison (a felony in any state in the US) for a stunt like Pussy Riot pulled, involving absolutely no property damage or physical harm? Or journalists critical of the regime being assassinated pretty frequently (with little hope of those murders ever being solved)? Or gay protesters being beaten in the streets?

Where are you living in the US that the exercise of government power seems somehow similar to all that?

Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by rdtsc on Friday August 17, 2012 @11:56PM (#4400179)
> I seriously couldn't tell: are you talking about Russia or the US here...?

Let me answer for him: "Yes"

Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by lionheart on Friday August 17, 2012 @11:11PM (#4400076)
Russia's population is a 1/3 of the US. Why would you use the # of votes as an absolute?
Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by Steko on Saturday August 18, 2012 @12:14AM (#4400217)
Because the person he was replying to framed it that way.
Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by maratd on Friday August 17, 2012 @11:05PM (#4400066)
Stalin was quite popular as well. What does popularity have to do with respecting basic human rights?

No, Putin isn't cartoonishly evil. In reality, he's actually quite nice when compared to the historical norm. Getting the shit beaten out of you or getting a few years in jail is actually kinda mild when you review the last 100 years in the motherland.

That's really not the point, anyway. Most of the negativity about Putin comes out from dissapointment. Most in the West actually thought Russia would change and would join the party.

Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by incosta on Friday August 17, 2012 @10:42PM (#4400010)
And as a Russian I think you better shut up in this case.

Things are'nt rosy for Putin indeed. And they're not as simplistic. I guess to make them simpler he got himself back in the office by rigging the vote and then by beating and arresting those who protest, Kasparov included?

Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by mladenkovacevic on Friday August 17, 2012 @11:06PM (#4400068)
And can I ask you something as a lover of irony: do you think he should shut up because he doesn't seem to value free-speech as much as you do?
Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by incosta on Friday August 17, 2012 @11:17PM (#4400091)
No, because what he said was a lie. And he knows it.
Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by old-gregg on Saturday August 18, 2012 @04:08AM (#4400556)
> And he knows it.

Ahhr... you caught me! I am being paid by the KGB for deliberately spreading misinformation on the Internet, recruit boy scouts into the Komsomol and paint Ulysses Grant's beard in black to make him look like Karl Marx on every $50 bill I get a hold of.

Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by incosta on Saturday August 18, 2012 @10:05AM (#4401150)
Paid or not, you do know that it's not possible to compare Obama and Putin in terms of popularity. Putin has been covered by all major channels in Russia exclusively for last 12 years, every single day. It's also not possible technically because he made a mockery of the elections process, and even then had to rig the vote. You also know that your claim about his popularity among Russians outside of Moscow is bogus but hardly verifiable to most people on HN: but he's just as disliked there as he is in Moscow. Don't portray Russian people as fools: they are not. And your talk about things not being so simple: how familiar. They are simple, my friend: Putin violated Russia's own laws including the Constitution, when he ran for the 3rd time, and he should not be the president, no matter how big you think his popularity is. He wants to rule forever? He will end up as a dictator. Simple as that.
Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by 1gor on Saturday August 18, 2012 @12:37PM (#4401527)
Look, my friend, you cannot deny that Russians overwhelmingly voted for Putin. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_presidential_election,_...

He got 64% of the total vote (45 million people). His closest opponent was a communist with 17%.

Now, how much votes did Putin steal? 10%? That would still leave him with twice as much votes as his next opponent. He'd still have the people's mandate.

It is quite possible that you do not like the choice of the majority of Russian people. But if you cannot accept result of a democratic election then you should not be making statements about Constitution and the law.

Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by incosta on Saturday August 18, 2012 @03:02PM (#4401946)
Look my friend, a guy in North Korea gets 100% of the vote. And Russia's poor friend Saddam Hussein got 99.9% on the most recent presidential "elections" he held. Putin, after 12 years of ceaseless propaganda should be ashamed to get the miserable 64% (of those rigged) votes. How much he stole does not really matter. He stole the election process itself. And he violated Russia's own Constitution by running for the 3rd time. Just like some of his comrade dictators. His gotcha moment. Welcome to the club!

P.S. Calling those "elections" democratic tells the whole story about you. Yes, you. They was nothing democratic about them, my Kremlin paid buddy.

Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by 1gor on Saturday August 18, 2012 @07:26PM (#4402657)
So, you say Russia is another North Korea? And anyone who disagrees with you is paid by Kremlin?

With opposition so bright, no wonder why Putin gets elected.

Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by incosta on Saturday August 18, 2012 @08:17PM (#4402762)
Anyone who knowing enough facts calls what happened earlier this year and back in December 2011 "democratic elections" is, in my opinion, being paid by the Kremlin. You are being paid by the Kremlin.

Putin should feel humiliated when he meets his North Korean friend Kim (err.. what's his name?) next time, for getting his officially announced miserable 64%.

Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by 1gor on Saturday August 18, 2012 @08:51PM (#4402831)

  You are being paid by the Kremlin
Yep. I registered this HN account five years ago especially to wait for your comments. And my real name is Anna Chapman.
Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by incosta on Saturday August 18, 2012 @09:34PM (#4402923)
I appreciate your confession.
Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by thinkingisfun on Saturday August 18, 2012 @10:49PM (#4403059)
if you cannot accept result of a democratic election then you should not be making statements about Constitution and the law.

Nah, it's exactly the other way around. I see you did not address this at all:

Putin violated Russia's own laws including the Constitution, when he ran for the 3rd time, and he should not be the president, no matter how big you think his popularity is.

Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by 1gor on Sunday August 19, 2012 @06:21AM (#4403711)
Russian Constitution forbids two consecutive terms. Putin served two, then endorsed his close associate for the presidency. The associated gets elected, serves a term, then steps aside. Putin runs again, and gets elected for the third term, but not a third consecutive term.

For many this looks like twisting the law, but Putin is genuinely popular among common people so most people are kind of happy he found a legal way around the limitations.

Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by smsm42 on Saturday August 18, 2012 @04:23AM (#4400585)
They are not "cartoonishly" evil. They are really evil. The elections were stolen, and everybody - including in Russia - knows it. Some think it's OK because "Putin is stability" but nobody thinks there is anything like free elections or democracy there. Nobody knows how many popular votes Putin got - exactly because he did not allow to count the votes fairly.

But it's not only stealing elections. It's also completely destroying judicial system - again, nobody believes there's such thing as independent judiciary anymore in Russia, it is jailing political opponents, it is stealing millions of dollars from the budget... Yes, things "aren't rosy". But I'd seriously suggest you to wake up and smell the roses, because the real evil is already there. And if history teaches us anything, it'll get much worse before it gets better. Russia has a history of leaders who imprisoned their political opponents. Nothing good came out of it, not once.

Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by 1gor on Saturday August 18, 2012 @04:54AM (#4400634)

  Nobody knows how many popular votes Putin got - exactly because 
  he did not allow to count the votes fairly.
Not many dispute Putin's personal election results, even the opposition. The parlamentary elections before that -- is another matter, they were substantially rigged in favour of the pro-government party.

And let me correct you -- 63% of the Russian voters who have voted for Putin believe that they live under democracy, and are very happy that their votes count and their candidate has won.

Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by smsm42 on Saturday August 18, 2012 @06:32AM (#4400768)
What are you talking about - of course many dispute it! There were mass protests about the election results, and multiple proven cases of fraud - which, of course, were never prosecuted due to absence of independent judiciary.

Again, quoting official results in obviously and proven rigged elections as evidence of "voters who have voted for Putin" is just disingenuous - do you really believe anybody would be swayed by the argument "Putin won elections because Putin says so"?

Also, the democracy is not only when majority wins. It is also when the rights of everybody are respected. Even if Putin had won the majority vote - which we do not know since there was no free and fair election - it would not absolve him from responsibility to preserve the rights of every citizen - including those who oppose him. That is clearly not happening.

Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by 1gor on Saturday August 18, 2012 @10:14AM (#4401182)
There were no mass protests after Putin election results. You can check for yourself http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011%E2%80%932012_Russian_prote...

There were 25 thousand people protesting in Moscow Pushking square immediately after his re-election on March 5, 2012. No major regional protests reported. Moscow has 11 million inhabitants, so 0.02% of them were protesting. I would not call them 'mass protests'.

In contrast, the protests about cases of fraud during Parliament elections rally on Bolotnaya square in December 2011 brought 60 thousand protesters in one day, and many more rallies have been reported throughout Russia.

On tens of March (I quote) "Another 'For Fair Elections' protest was staged on the Novy Arbat street in Moscow. A permit was issued for 50,000,... but just 25,000 thousand came according to the organisers and 10,000 according to the police. The mood was downbeat after Putin won an absolute majority everywhere but Moscow where he garnered 46.95% of the vote. Sergei Udaltsov of Left Front, called for a massive demonstration 1 May, but no further protests are scheduled".

Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by guard-of-terra on Saturday August 18, 2012 @12:27PM (#4401504)
The problem is: the other 40% were screwed again -- the same 40% were screwed on every russian presidential elections ever. There were no elections with "unorthodox" result -- there is no choice. The lack of choice and circulation hurts the credibility of the regime.
Re:Garry Kasparov Arrested By Russian Police by vacri on Friday August 17, 2012 @11:12PM (#4400080)
A Russian friend of mine reminds me that the things Putin does to show his manliness (like riding barechested through the woods and going on bear hunts) are just as ridiculous to Russians as they would be to us if our own politicians did the same.