Re:A Proposal To Improve Hacker News
by GnarlinBrando on Friday August 17, 2012 @07:49PM
(#4399473)
This would graduate HN away from the list of links model that is so prevalent. Certainly an interesting idea, but a big change as well.
Maybe instead of adding a comment, you could also have a button to add another link covering the same topic. Good for when someone links a BGR story that's just a linkbait headline summary of a BI article that's just a rewrite of a NYT interview. So let's say all articles for a common topic become linked. Allow upvotes on articles and the highest one becomes titular for the meta-thread.
This would (1) condense topics so the front page isn't deluged with say 5 twitter api threads, (2) unify discussions and avoid repetition, (3) help enforce good net practices i.e. linking to the best source.