News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How We Nearly Lost the Discovery Shuttle by rdl on Friday August 17, 2012 @07:16PM (#4399341)
The lesson I take from this is that the Shuttle should have been killed on the drawing board, never flown. It's a hideously complex design with no real advantages over expendable or re-usable rockets. It might have made sense as part of a tens of trillions of dollar integrated infrastructure plan (as originally proposed in the 1970s), but once those elements were killed, zombie/frankenstein shuttle wasn't the right answer.

NASA could have focused more on great science programs (like the Mars rovers, unmanned deep space probes, planetary science -- think of what they could accomplish with even 50% of the current overall NASA budget), military and government launch could have continued with ICBM-derived rockets, and private space could have gotten an earlier start.

Re:How We Nearly Lost the Discovery Shuttle by wissler on Friday August 17, 2012 @07:39PM (#4399424)
> The lesson I take from this is that the Shuttle should have been killed on the drawing board, never flown.

Exactly, yes. The design should have been revised until they weren't pushing safety margins so hard. Of course, that would have been an engineer-led approach, which is the opposite approach from the one they used.