So it would have even worse implications for anyone complaining, who isn’t clearly way beyond that threshold.
It could.
> since most of those types are in fact smarter than the ~80th-90th percentile.
But you’re skipping the very issue of this mindset. Being smarter along a very specific scale of evaluation doesn’t make one de facto « smarter » in general, neither properly adjusted to work and collaborate in an organisation.
Denouncing arrogance might not be the best move in some context, but it is not a show of weakness.
They’re not going to assume the author is any more virtuous/wise/etc… than the complained against, without some compelling evidence.
A minor signal is still a signal, that may, or may not, accrue to other converging ones.
I don’t see the connection to how any random group of HN readers perceive this or that.
You mean “survive” in their desired neighborhoods?
Well... that may as well be a very clinical observation; I've lost count of how many I've met in interviewing rounds, on either side of the table or in my own teams. It wouldn't surprise me a lot of tech people go through such a phase, at some (hopefully as shortest as possible) point of their early career. I probably have.