Re:Multiple Security Issues in GNU Screen
by layer8 on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @01:15PM
(#43975292)
You generally can’t transparently replace a tool by a different one like that, siblings are giving examples of where there would be incompatibilities. There would also be much upheaval among users if a distribution would try to underhandedly perform such a replacement. If anything, a package “tmux-as-screen” could be provided for those who want that.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Multiple Security Issues in GNU Screen
by Wowfunhappy on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @07:53PM
(#43979196)
> If anything, a package “tmux-as-screen” could be provided for those who want that.
To be clear, that's what I was imagining. If you had a shell script that called screen, it would now work via tmux, but no one would be "tricked".
In that case, nobody would be tricked because they would have to explicitly select that package. Those already having screen installed, or selecting screen for installation, wouldn’t automatically be upgraded to tmux-as-screen. So what the comment you replied to mentioned as a problem of inertia and there being “no immediate incentive to switch” would remain largely unaddressed.
Re:Multiple Security Issues in GNU Screen
by Wowfunhappy on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @08:13PM
(#43979335)
Well, I guess the other part would be removing screen from the official repo. So the original utility is gone, but we have a compatibility package you can install that should make things work like they used to. (Of course, if you really still want screen you can build from source or some such.)