What are the specifics on that? Like does the vulnerability need to be public or is it enough if just the vendor knows about it? Does everyone need to stop selling it right away if new vulnerability is discovered or do they some time patch it? I'm pretty sure software like Windows almost definitely has some unfixed vulnerabilities that Microsoft knows about and is in process of fixing every single day of the year. Currently even if they do have a fix, they would end up postponing it until next patch Tuesday.
And what even is "vulnerability" in this context? Remote RCE? DRM bypass?
Note that in the legal text above there is language stating what requirements from the annexes applies to what hard/software.
As far as I know (I haven't read the text fully) selling stuff is fine if the end user can update their software.
There is no clear description of what "vulnerability" entails. The definitions do include things like:
‘vulnerability’ means a weakness, susceptibility or flaw of a product with digital elements that can be exploited by a cyber threat;
‘cyber threat’ means a cyber threat as defined in Article 2, point (8), of Regulation (EU) 2019/881;
‘cybersecurity risk’ means the potential for loss or disruption caused by an incident and is to be expressed as a combination of the magnitude of such loss or disruption and the likelihood of occurrence of the incident;The "including the possibility to reset the product to its original state" is interesting one, would that prevent manufacturers from not allowing user to downgrade to original version (via eFuses)? 5.3.3.1 on those guidelines does say "initial or newest version", but that doesn't really sound like original state.
>instead of them saying it allows for arbitrary/remote code execution they say it “may allow untrusted sources to affect system behaviour”.
Sounds like Asus did in fact deny the bug.
Do stores have to patch known vulnerabilities before releasing the product to customers or can customers install the patch?
Basically, the manufacturer has to issue a patch, and the distributor has to ensure that the patch is available before selling the vulnerable devices. Without secure software, the product is essentially CE-incompliant, which means it practically isn't allowed to be sold.
IANAL though.
Well your analogy just proves my point, LOL.
The EU mandates that you take driving school lessons and pass an appropriate examination. Some countries go even further and demand regular medical checkups (Italy does so for senior citizens, if you're 80+ it's once every two years). And if you manage to get in the spotlight for too many or too egregious violations, your license gets suspended to permanently revoked, in addition to some serious fines and the requirement to undergo further evaluation or even therapy (e.g. if you're facing substance addiction issues).
Use that analogy on software/firmware for appliances, and then you get:
- an initial independent certification requirement before introduction into the market - and no, CE doesn't count: all that "CE" signifies is that you as the manufacturer/importer believe your product is conforming to regulations. For many products (IIRC, everything but medical products and devices containing radio transmitters), that's it, you don't even have to go to a third party like the TÜV for a formal audit.
- obligations if you manage to stand out with security issues, including a temporary order to not sell any more units until they are reworked
- getting permanently booted off the market if your violations are too serious.
An immediate sales stop and recall is certainly appropriate when food endangers people's health, I'm not sure it is the right decision in this case. You could give manufacturers some time to fix it, and only then stopping the sales. This way they would still be incentivised to quickly make a fix, but avoid the potentially huge economic downside, which will lead to higher barriers of entry and probably further consolidation, hurting consumers in a different way. Remember that regulation always benefits the incumbents.
Normal people don't care about vulnerabilities. They use phones that haven't received updates in three years to do their finances. If you spam the news with CVEs, people will just get tired of hearing about how every company sucks and become apathetic once there's a real threat.
The EU is working on a different solution. Stores are not permitted to sell products with known vulnerabilities under new cybersecurity regulations. That means if ASUS keeps fucking up, their motherboards become dead stock and stores won't want to sell their hardware anymore. That's not just computer hardware, but also smart fridges and smart washing machines. Discover a vulnerability in your dish washer and you may end up costing the dish washer industry millions in unusable stock if their vendors haven't bothered to add a way to update the firmware.