Re:Odin, a Pragmatic C Alternative with a Go Flavour
by teo_zero on Saturday May 10, 2025 @01:56AM
(#43943509)
> "Better-C" still has things many C-programmers wouldn't particularly like
I'd say a couple, not many.
> RAII
Who wouldn't like RAII?
> Metaprogramming
As a way to avoid preprocessor macros? Yes please.
> Nested functions
Already offered as extension.
> Member functions
I'm sure no C programmer would object to that.
> constructors, destructors
This yes. Agreed.
> operating overloading
Instead of _Generic()? Why not?
Re:Odin, a Pragmatic C Alternative with a Go Flavour
by gingerBill on Saturday May 10, 2025 @05:15AM
(#43944291)
I wouldn't like RAII, and why I didn't add it to Odin. It's not a feature C programmers want. And you've just agreed that C don't want ctors/dtors, which is necessary for RAII to work... ctors/dtors are bad for their own reasons (mainly because you cannot handle error cases except through exceptions, which many people disable too).
D's scope seems to go far beyond what your average C programmer would want in a language; "use only 15% of the language and you'll be fine" (paraphrasing: "use only the 'better-C' subset", if that is what you meant, and it does seem to be a subset of D) seems a weird proposition; it still complicates things, as in collaboration, idiomatic feel and look of code, the amount of knowledge required to be competent in the language, complexity of a compiler implementation, portability of code etc... and by that logic you'd have to prefer C++ over C as well (since a lot of C is valid C++), or prefer C plus one safety feature added over C; but the "rawness"/limited scope/small size/procedural nature of C is what's appealing for many to begin with.
I for one think that a proper C replacement (C's strength also being the simplicity in which to implement a compiler for example, being the reason it's so ubiquitous in the embedded world) will be a much more limited proposition than D is.
Edit: And having been curious, even "Better-C" still has things many C-programmers wouldn't particularly like. Going by things listed here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/D_(programming_language)
Where to draw the line will be different person to person, but D doesn't seem to be a language "in the spirit of C", or a "modern version of it", at all.Viewing it as a C++ alternative makes much more sense. A `Better-C` "limit yourself to a subset of the language" compiler flag doesn't change that much.