News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by AdamN on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:01PM (#43938306)
I'm sure one of the libertarians on HN will get defensive here and tell us how Musk, Thiel, et al. are doing a great job and how wrong you are. This community is part of the problem for enabling this anti-science, anti-intellectual culture to fester in the Republican party and now to be in charge.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by fallingknife on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:14PM (#43938446)
Couldn't find the person you wanted to argue with in the comments so you just pretended they are here and claim the community is "part of the problem" even though you couldn't actually find one of them.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by sneak on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:03PM (#43938336)
True libertarians are disgusted by authoritarians.

A reduction in the size of the US federal government (and its budget) is long overdue.

Both of these things can be true.

It isn’t anti-intellectual to say that most of what the US federal government does would be better performed by private industry.

If understanding is your goal, it may be a useful intellectual exercise to internally steelman the counterargument to your own position.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by ab5tract on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:12PM (#43938428)
> It isn’t anti-intellectual to say that most of what the US federal government does would be better performed by private industry.

Considering this is simply a religious statement posing as an assertion of fact, I would argue it is anti-intellectual to an extreme.

Please share some libertarian paradises where this has proven true. How’s Kentucky doing again?

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by kevinventullo on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:59PM (#43939489)
It isn’t anti-intellectual to say that most of what the US federal government does would be better performed by private industry.

The problem is that industry is inherently narrowly focused in short-to-medium term profitability, and cannot be relied on to carry out work which benefits society as a whole, including many conventionally “intellectual” pursuits such as: educating the populace, or fundamental research with no clear path to monetization.

Yes, private schools do both of these things, but in both cases they are only doing so by means of public funding.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by sneak on Friday May 09, 2025 @02:42PM (#43939833)
Some industries are. Many industries do not. Pharmaceutical companies and aerospace companies are frequently investing in long term projects.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by kevinventullo on Friday May 09, 2025 @03:39PM (#43940278)
Long-term projects with a fairly well-paved path to monetization. If industry was willing to invest in things like pure mathematics, or deep space astronomy, or just generally subsidizing smart people to investigate things they think are interesting, we wouldn’t need the NSF.

The point is that the efficiency of the private sector is a Faustian bargain: it comes at the cost of expecting an ROI for the investigators.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by const_cast on Friday May 09, 2025 @07:13PM (#43941811)
A small minority of the private sector is burning money on long-term investments. Another small minority are burning money on ventures which cannot be monetized. At their intersection, there exists zero companies. Yes, zero. Not close to zero, just zero. And it will always be zero.

How will you survive if what you're doing takes both a lot of time and makes no money?

Think about something like the FDA. It's a cost sink. The private sector will never do something like that because it's explicitly anti-profit.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by saagarjha on Saturday May 10, 2025 @04:44AM (#43944161)
Aren't both heavily propped up with government funding?
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by sneak on Saturday May 10, 2025 @06:01PM (#43949359)
I don’t believe so, no, but even if they were - isn’t funding private businesses to do research (that have a stake in success) better than the state doing it directly and not caring if it works or is effective or not?
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by AdamN on Monday May 12, 2025 @07:07AM (#43961717)
You'd have to make that case. Even the naive answer would be 'no' but I can't think of a reason why a narrowly focused business is better than a government-backed enterprise when it comes to doing research. It's not worse necessarily, but it's not better either.