Re:MicroEval (YC S12) Aims To Take The Pain Out Of Performan...
by ernestipark on Thursday August 16, 2012 @02:53PM
(#4392999)
The legal aspect of performance reviews is definitely one not to overlook. We believe having record of performance and reviews is important. However, I think you would probably see that in companies where the evaluations are solely intended as a legal tool, that both employees and management/HR probably hate them. An incredible amount of value is waiting to be tapped when performance reviews are done right.
Re:MicroEval (YC S12) Aims To Take The Pain Out Of Performan...
by rjsamson on Thursday August 16, 2012 @02:52PM
(#4392995)
In the US we have at will employment, so using performance reviews primarily for evidence to fire people is not going to something that is common.
Re:MicroEval (YC S12) Aims To Take The Pain Out Of Performan...
by thaumasiotes on Thursday August 16, 2012 @03:04PM
(#4393058)
Nominal at-will employment might not provide all the protection you would expect. For example, though the employer may end an at-will contract for "any" reason, certain reasons are legally prohibited.
Further, you might want to read http://www.huffingtonpost.com/aaron-greenspan/why-i-sued-goo... for an example of court thinking:
'In fact, clause 6 of the AdSense for Content Terms and Conditions does not allow Google to terminate accounts for "no" reason--only "any" reason. Much to my amusement, the judge interrupted her to make a point that sounded familiar.
"But you couldn't terminate my account because of the color of my eyes, could you? I have brown eyes. You couldn't terminate my account because of that."
Ms. Milani reiterated her previous arguments, but the judge didn't buy them.'
Personally, I would argue that "the guy has brown eyes" is sufficient "any" reason, but I appear to be losing the popular battle.
Re:MicroEval (YC S12) Aims To Take The Pain Out Of Performan...
by rjsamson on Thursday August 16, 2012 @04:38PM
(#4393534)
You're correct. My only point is that it is not enough of an issue here in the US that accumulating evidence to fire somebody is not a primary reason to institute performance reviews company-wide (in general).
This is a (slightly) different area, but during my year as a teacher, my much more experienced coworker, who came from the New Jersey system, couldn't emphasize enough that anytime a "problem" student committed any infraction, no matter how minor, he wanted us to write it down. He was quite explicit that this documentation should be based on our view of the student, not the conduct, and that the purpose was that, should a parent complain about actions we were taking against their child, we wanted to have a huge file of infractions to show off.
(Clarification of "based on the student, not the conduct" -- otherwise good student commits an infraction that might merit discipline ("She punched through the girls' bathroom window"). We don't care. Awful student commits a minor infraction ("Talking in class"). We write it down.)