Re:June Huh dropped out to become a poet, now he’s won a Fie...
by ldjkfkdsjnv on Thursday May 08, 2025 @08:48AM
(#43925594)
You are talking about current capabilities versus what is probably possible. Sure, its not possible to write proofs with an LLM right now.
Somewhere inside openai is a reinforcement learning loop that looks like:
current_code = read(code_base_from_file.txt)
modify_prompt = "some prompt to modify code with expected outcome"
result = model.run(modify_prompt, current_code)
if check(result):
provide_positive_feedback(model)
else: provide_negative_feedback(model)
and its clear that not only does this work, it maybe the future of what unravels software engineering.the current models are being trained for coding, but theres no reason this couldnt be tried for other domains, like pure math.
Re:June Huh dropped out to become a poet, now he’s won a Fie...
by cycrutchfield on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:34PM
(#43927918)
Wow, so easy. Why didn’t anybody think of that before? How shall I inscribe your Fields Medal, sir?
Re:June Huh dropped out to become a poet, now he’s won a Fie...
by wizzwizz4 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @04:18PM
(#43930859)
It's not possible to write (usefully novel) proofs with an LLM, but we have other algorithms that can do that. Perhaps a reinforcement learning component could improve upon the search strategy in some way, but there's no compelling reason to use a predictive text model. (There's not even good reason to believe that naïve reinforcement learning would improve the mathematical ability of a system: RL says "that was good: do more of that", and mathematics is about discovery: thinking thoughts that nobody has ever thought before.)
Terry Tao is one of the staunchest knowledgeable advocates of GPT models in mathematical research, and afaik he doesn't even bother trying to use the models for proof search. It's like trying to build a house with a box of shoes: sure, the shoe is technically more versatile because you can't use a hammer for tightening bolts (the shoe's sole has enough friction to do this) or foot protection (the shoe is the right shape for this) or electrical isolation (the bottom surface of the shoe is largely rubber), but please just use a hammer if you want to manipulate nails.