To me it is absolutely certain that ToM made a concious effort to copy the style of Fab, through the composition and presentation of individual elements and the layout of the site.
Branding is very important and can very easily confuse consumers, maybe Fab are being overzealous and should have just asked ToM to stop copying their branding, but to claim that because lots of websites have clock graphics next to their timers that this isn't a copy is silly.
Whether or not they will win in court is irrelevant, what matters is that what Fab.com is claiming (ToM copied them) is (in my opinion) an accurate claim.
Their lawyers know that they most likely aren't going to win this--they're just trying to force them to pay legal costs they can't afford.
In essence they are pursing a fairly frivolous lawsuit for the sole purpose of removing competition.
37signals should start suing all the SaaS websites that were inspired by Basecamp.
A quick google shows that in fact this is sarcastic.
A generic tag icon next to the item price, in a different color? A "sale ending" notice with different color, location, and font?