News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge said Meta illegally used books to build its AI by triceratops on Monday May 05, 2025 @11:44AM (#43896307)
So Meta borrowed every book from a library and paid to obtain all of the movies and TV shows? They kept only one copy of every book at any time on their system?

Because I'm certainly not allowed to photocopy a library book in its entirety. And I guarantee you a Netflix subscription doesn't allow me to keep a copy of a movie on my hard drive and use it for training man or machine.

Re:Judge said Meta illegally used books to build its AI by throwawaymaths on Monday May 05, 2025 @12:38PM (#43896921)
> Because I'm certainly not allowed to photocopy a library book in its entirety.

IANAL but that probably falls under fair use? You'll get in trouble if you photocopy the work and sell access to it.

Re:Judge said Meta illegally used books to build its AI by 3036e4 on Monday May 05, 2025 @01:05PM (#43897179)
Depends on where you live. In Sweden you can make a few copies of almost anything without violating copyright. There are a few exceptions. Copying entire books was added as an exception in 2005. You can still copy parts of a book. How large parts? I don't know, but I once asked for a copy from a library and they said that a few chapters was fine, so maybe that much (I am not a lawyer).
Re:Judge said Meta illegally used books to build its AI by triceratops on Monday May 05, 2025 @01:46PM (#43897577)
> but that probably falls under fair use?

I've not found case law for that. I've had this same argument on HN multiple times over the past few months.