Re:Seeking an Answer: Why can't HTML alone do includes?
by elevaet on Sunday May 04, 2025 @09:25AM
(#43886583)
Also even if you do have good practices of semantic tagging, there are huge epistemological problems around taxonomies - who constructs them, what do the terms actually mean, how to organize them and so on.
In my experience trying to work with wikidata taxonomies, it can be a total mess when it's crowdsourced, and if you go to am "expert" derived taxonomy there are all kinds of other problems with coverage, meaning, democracy.
I've had a few flirtations with the semantic web going back to 2007 and long ago came to the personal conclusion that unfortunately AI is the only viable approach.
People wanted to write and publish. Only a small portion of people/institutions would have had the resources or appetite to tag factual information on their pages. Most people would have ignored the semantic taxonomies (or just wouldn't have published at all). I guess a small and insular semantic web is better than no semantic web, but I doubt there was a scenario where the web would have been as rich as it actually became, but was also rigidly organized.