News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FAA offering more incentives as air traffic controller sh... by monero-xmr on Saturday May 03, 2025 @06:53PM (#43883016)
It would be great if actually needed, demanding government jobs could pay a market rate. And even better, we could somehow pay better people more. And even even better - fire poor performers. The more-less lockstep pay scales across the US government are bizarre, as well as government unions, negotiating with politicians. As FDR said:

> All Government employees should realize that the process of collective bargaining, as usually understood, cannot be transplanted into the public service. It has its distinct and insurmountable limitations when applied to public personnel management. The very nature and purposes of Government make it impossible for administrative officials to represent fully or to bind the employer in mutual discussions with Government employee organizations. The employer is the whole people, who speak by means of laws enacted by their representatives in Congress. Accordingly, administrative officials and employees alike are governed and guided, and in many instances restricted, by laws which establish policies, procedures, or rules in personnel matters.

> Particularly, I want to emphasize my conviction that militant tactics have no place in the functions of any organization of Government employees.

> … Since their own services have to do with the functioning of the Government, a strike of public employees manifests nothing less than an intent on their part to prevent or obstruct the operations of Government until their demands are satisfied. Such action, looking toward the paralysis of Government by those who have sworn to support it, is unthinkable and intolerable. It is, therefore, with a feeling of gratification that I have noted in the constitution of the National Federation of Federal Employees the provision that "under no circumstances shall this Federation engage in or support strikes against the United States Government.”

- FDR, 1937 https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/documents/letter-the-resolut...

Re:FAA offering more incentives as air traffic controller sh... by duxup on Saturday May 03, 2025 @07:07PM (#43883086)
The limits on government salaries seems entirely counterproductive.

I am all for evaluating things in an effort to establish more government efficiency.

But that means you need smart people who understand that domain evaluating, and you need to be able to bring smart people on board to do the work…. not artificially low wages/ arbitrary cuts…

Re:FAA offering more incentives as air traffic controller sh... by jedberg on Saturday May 03, 2025 @07:12PM (#43883108)
The limits are there to limit corruption.

If managers could set arbitrary salaries, the employees could just agree to cut their manager in on 10% of their raise.

This probably happens outside of government, but it's just the private org who loses money, so it's up to them to stop it. But in the case of the government, it's the taxpayers who lose.

Re:FAA offering more incentives as air traffic controller sh... by spangry on Saturday May 03, 2025 @07:31PM (#43883203)
I think that’s right - more discretion creates more room for corruption.

Although there are other ways to limit corruption risk, namely process and transparency. In the Australian government you can pay someone higher than standard pay through an Individual Flexibility Agreement (IFA). But in order to do so there’s a whole process the manager has to go through where they have to justify the higher salary on a limited set of grounds (e.g. higher market value of role) and then get it all signed off by someone higher up the chain.

That’s the process side. On the transparency side you could publish everyone’s salaries and then it becomes obvious when a manger is paying their second cousin way above normal for some strange reason.

Re:FAA offering more incentives as air traffic controller sh... by duxup on Saturday May 03, 2025 @07:17PM (#43883133)
I don’t think managers (even without limits) could just set salaries… it’s not like they all just pay the max at manager discretion now.
Re:FAA offering more incentives as air traffic controller sh... by jedberg on Saturday May 03, 2025 @07:22PM (#43883156)
Government salaries are based on objective measures today -- years of service and job role. There is no "merit" part or anything subjective.

To move to a system where "good people make more money", someone has to decide who the "good" people are. That person is susceptible to corruption. Moreso than in a private enterprise and with wider consequences, because government is not a business. So overpaying people doesn't have the same consequences as doing it privately.

Re:FAA offering more incentives as air traffic controller sh... by Jtsummers on Saturday May 03, 2025 @07:33PM (#43883221)
NSPS was an attempt to push towards something more merit based (still pay band structured, NSPS bands spanned 2-3 GS grades). NSPS was rolled back in 2010 or so because the requirement was that everyone had to be on it by 2009 (early 2010?) and that didn't happen.

There are various *demo (lab, acq, I think some others) that are basically the same as NSPS (in principle) and ostensibly merit based. But they're also capped because of the correspondence to GS grades. Pay can increase much faster, in theory, than under GS but also you can be denied any raise except the general pay increase (below inflation, so a real pay cut even if a nominal pay raise) if your performance is poor.

Re:FAA offering more incentives as air traffic controller sh... by ThunderSizzle on Saturday May 03, 2025 @07:35PM (#43883229)
Years of service is a form of corruption, since years of service isn't a proxy for performance
Re:FAA offering more incentives as air traffic controller sh... by Jtsummers on Saturday May 03, 2025 @07:57PM (#43883338)
GS pay raises are only time-based in-grade, called steps. Each grade has 10 steps and if you start at step 1 it can take up to 18 years to reach step 10 (less if you have good performance because then you can get a bonus step increase). Most people don't start at step 1, though, so maxing out typically takes less time.

There are some jobs that will push you through grades on some regular cadence (usually 6-12 months in each grade), but those are usually "internships". New hires getting brought in at $50-60k/year GS-5 or GS-7 positions and moved up over 2-4 years into a GS-11 or GS-12 position. After that, they're back to competing for positions again for anything higher than GS-11/12 or whatever their target grade was.

Re:FAA offering more incentives as air traffic controller sh... by QuadmasterXLII on Saturday May 03, 2025 @08:38PM (#43883548)
corruption is a word with a meaning
Re:FAA offering more incentives as air traffic controller sh... by philwelch on Saturday May 03, 2025 @07:44PM (#43883280)
Most managers even in the private sector couldn’t really pull this off because they would need someone to approve the requested salary. You’d have to have a whole pyramid scheme of kickbacks going all the way up to the top executives, but the top executives have no incentive to cooperate because they’re already pulling a similar scheme against the shareholders for their salaries.
Re:FAA offering more incentives as air traffic controller sh... by fallingknife on Saturday May 03, 2025 @11:32PM (#43884272)
If the limits are to prevent corruption, why do they have to be so far below market rates? I don't think anyone is objecting to there being limits. Every company out there has level based limits. The issue is where those limits are set.
Re:FAA offering more incentives as air traffic controller sh... by monero-xmr on Saturday May 03, 2025 @07:12PM (#43883109)
Then the question is, “how do we prevent politicians from hiring their family and friends on excessive salaries”?

Then it’s, “how do we quantify success without the profit motive for something society needs, but doesn’t earn a profit”?

Then I would conclude, the solution is a small government with a hyper-competitive process for providing public services, with actual democratic feedback on the success of such provided services with teeth to remove bad private sector contractors.

Re:FAA offering more incentives as air traffic controller sh... by fn-mote on Saturday May 03, 2025 @08:32PM (#43883511)
> with actual democratic feedback on the success of such provided services

The Chicago political machine is calling. They want your jobs. All of your jobs.

Wait until you’re doing a great job but have the wrong political take on a situation.

Make sure you’re regularly doing favors for people and giving out what freebies you can so you stay in office during the next cycle.

It sounded great in the post, but democracy is hard so don’t expect an easy answer.

Re:FAA offering more incentives as air traffic controller sh... by duxup on Saturday May 03, 2025 @11:12PM (#43884178)
Is that the concern? Hiring family?

But they don’t because of the salary limit?

I don’t think that’s the case.

Re:FAA offering more incentives as air traffic controller sh... by jltsiren on Saturday May 03, 2025 @08:25PM (#43883480)
Easier firing would increase the market rates for every role. At least unless combined with generous unemployment benefits, as in Denmark. It could make the government more efficient in the long term, at the expense of higher spending (and therefore higher taxes) in the short term. Which many voters would not like.

The issue with unions negotiating with politicians is mostly a consequence of an excessive number of political appointees. Many things would be cleaner with more career civil servants in top positions. Top officials would have fixed-term appointments, and they could not join unions or be fired without a criminal conviction. They would run their departments, while political appointees would only set the goals and directions with little direct control. And then the rest would be more like ordinary employees who just happen to be working for the government.

Government employees are a mostly irrelevant category anyway. Depending on the time and place, the exact same job can be performed by an actual government employee, outsourced to a private contractor, or done by an employee of a company fully owned by the government. What the employee can or cannot do should depend more on the actual role than on the administrative structures above them.