News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber Boston Has Been Served by andrewpi on Tuesday August 14, 2012 @06:23PM (#4383376)
Except Uber isn't a cab, it's a private car service, which is generally less regulated. Rates for private car services are generally negotiated between the driver and passenger, and if both parties agree to use Uber's GPS-based software, I don't see what Massachusetts's problem is.
Re:Uber Boston Has Been Served by mikeryan on Tuesday August 14, 2012 @07:59PM (#4383704)
The argument they are making is that both parties are agreeing to traveling a certain distance for a certain price. But the tool which measures the distance must be an approved measurement device in order to prevent fraud.

I can agree to pay my super market a dollar for a pound of apples, but the dept. of weights and measures still validates the scale. That's the consumer protection that the state is arguing for.

Note the whole is it a cab or isn't it argument isn't actually germaine to this complaint (they actually dropped the unlicensed livery service complaint) its wholly based on the legitimacy of the measuring device

Re:Uber Boston Has Been Served by jellicle on Wednesday August 15, 2012 @02:17PM (#4387329)
If Uber were using flat rates, this problem wouldn't exist. But Uber is actually selling miles-in-a-cab, and the government is rightfully pointing out that due to a very extensive history of businesses manipulating weights and measures to increase profits, the measuring device used to measure miles-in-a-cab ought to be one that has been inspected by the government.
Re:Uber Boston Has Been Served by jaylevitt on Tuesday August 14, 2012 @07:51PM (#4383677)
More importantly, Uber is neither a cab NOR a private car service.

It's a communications network that links private car services with people who want to get a ride from the private car service.

Re:Uber Boston Has Been Served by untog on Wednesday August 15, 2012 @12:08AM (#4384543)
Given that they handle payments, its considerably more than a communication network.
Re:Uber Boston Has Been Served by jaylevitt on Wednesday August 15, 2012 @07:32AM (#4385440)
True - it's a marketplace, eBay for livery services.
Re:Uber Boston Has Been Served by rprasad on Wednesday August 15, 2012 @03:06PM (#4387599)
By that definition, no cab companies are cabs, since that is exactly what the cab companies do--arrange trips between independently contracted cab drivers and potential customers.

Under the legal definition of cab services in many municipalities, Uber is a cab service rather than a livery service. In other municipalities, Uber is merely a livery service. In the U.S., each municipality gets to define what a cab service and a livery service are (because that is a local power under the federal system of government).