Re:Virginia passes law to enforce maximum vehicle speeds for...
by Animats on Monday April 28, 2025 @02:25AM
(#43818212)
> In fact, most cars lie to you about the speed - reporting a speed slightly faster than reality. It's a cover-your-ass measure for the car manufacturers because it's illegal to sell a car (in the US, at least) where the speedometer is inaccurate in the other direction, that is, reading slower than actual speed.
Haven't seen that in a long time. Everything I've driven in recent years has a speedometer speed that matches roadside speed sign speed within 1 MPH.
Re:Virginia passes law to enforce maximum vehicle speeds for...
by kuratkull on Monday April 28, 2025 @03:01AM
(#43818416)
My experience from all the cars i have driven is that GPS shows 3-5km/h less than the car does. (In Europe)
Re:Virginia passes law to enforce maximum vehicle speeds for...
by Cthulhu_ on Monday April 28, 2025 @04:53AM
(#43819075)
That's actually a legal requirement (had to google some to get the source): [0]. And a graph: [1]
[0] https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:42...
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/16mquqv/sp...
Re:Virginia passes law to enforce maximum vehicle speeds for...
by kuratkull on Monday April 28, 2025 @09:48AM
(#43821512)
The graph seems a bit too much. It says that GPS 110 means ~125 on the odo. Although from personal experience I'd say it's more around a delta of 5 at those speeds, and 3 for lower speeds.
Re:Virginia passes law to enforce maximum vehicle speeds for...
by detaro on Monday April 28, 2025 @09:51AM
(#43821537)
it has to fall somewhere in the shaded area. So if it shows 125, then the actual speed must be between 125 and 110 at worst.
Re:Virginia passes law to enforce maximum vehicle speeds for...
by urban_winter on Monday April 28, 2025 @02:43AM
(#43818328)
My 5-year-old Volvo reports 73-74 mph when GPS tells me that I'm exactly at 70mph. Similarly 21 mph when GPS says 20.
Re:Virginia passes law to enforce maximum vehicle speeds for...
by dheera on Monday April 28, 2025 @02:50PM
(#43824659)
If the law set the speed limit as the hard boundary, with hard punishments for driving at 70, everyone else would drive at 65, occasionally getting close to 68-69.
If the reasonable speed for a road is 70, the legal hard limit could be at 75 to be considerate of this effect. But make 75 the actual hard limit with $200 fines for hitting 75, $1000 fines for hitting 80, and jail time for hitting 85. Make it almost certain to be caught if you hit these hard limits.
I guarantee you fewer people would die on the roads if this is the way things worked.
In fact, most cars lie to you about the speed - reporting a speed slightly faster than reality. It's a cover-your-ass measure for the car manufacturers because it's illegal to sell a car (in the US, at least) where the speedometer is inaccurate in the other direction, that is, reading slower than actual speed.
1. Some older vehicles, including pre-1996 GM trucks (and probably others from the same era) had the speedometer calibration controlled by a resistor array on a circuit board under the dash, those can be changed with a lot of effort and a soldering iron, or by swapping out the whole circuit board with a different one that matches your tire size + rear end gear ratio.