Re:Virginia passes law to enforce maximum vehicle speeds for...
by exsomet on Monday April 28, 2025 @12:13AM
(#43817479)
You’re forgetting a step - which, being a hardware designer instead of a lawyer, is understandable.
The fourth amendment means that there should never be a situation where you are arbitrarily required to provide the government access to, or information about, the ways that you use or modify private property like a vehicle.
Re:Virginia passes law to enforce maximum vehicle speeds for...
by steveBK123 on Monday April 28, 2025 @12:21AM
(#43817518)
Maybe.
But driving is not a constitutional right.
Break the law enough and you can be provided two options - revocation of license or installation of limiter.
Re:Virginia passes law to enforce maximum vehicle speeds for...
by atoav on Monday April 28, 2025 @12:25AM
(#43817544)
No I did not forget it, I was responding to an technical argument with an technical answer. And I am the type of person who wouldn't design such a system if you held a gun up to my head.
Of course there is a legal layer to this as well. But given how the US legal system treats other constitutional rights that ought to be valid for everybody on American soil at the moment, I thought I'd skip that for now, because apparently something being a constitutional right doesn't make it so.
Re:Virginia passes law to enforce maximum vehicle speeds for...
by sroussey on Monday April 28, 2025 @12:36AM
(#43817602)
You mean, like, AT&T and phone calls?
Re:Virginia passes law to enforce maximum vehicle speeds for...
by toomuchtodo on Monday April 28, 2025 @01:23AM
(#43817854)
We already require breathalyzer interlocks be installed for habitual DUI drivers in a majority of states. This is an extension of that same legal principle. Road access is a privilege (as evidenced by the requirement to have a driver’s license and vehicle tags).
https://www.ncsl.org/transportation/state-ignition-interlock...
Aside from that cars phone bome anyways as ot is, so another way to crossreference data.
This can be as nontrivial as you want it. The problem is rather that a state shouldn't treat its citizens like that. That is probably why they start with repeat offenders.