News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Read the Obits by kenjackson on Sunday April 27, 2025 @03:56PM (#43814632)
Does there exist anything related to creativity that is backed up with clear data? This article is as convincing as anything else I’ve ever read about increasing creativity.
Re:Read the Obits by PhearTheCeal on Sunday April 27, 2025 @04:33PM (#43814882)
> Complex training courses, meditation and cultural exposure were most effective (gs = 0.66), while the use of cognitive manipulation drugs was least and also non-effective, g = 0.10. The type of training material was also important. For instance, figural methods were more effective in enhancing creativity, and enhancing converging thinking was more effective than enhancing divergent thinking.

from https://edoc.hu-berlin.de/items/a8357c0b-1e41-4eff-8ad1-fe3b...

reading the obits might fall under "cultural exposure".

Re:Read the Obits by gwern on Sunday April 27, 2025 @04:57PM (#43815074)
There's lots of legitimate research related to creativity which could be discussed: the existence of the 'incubation effect' and sleep effects, the inefficacy of the popular forms of 'brainstorming' compared to the more painful forms that work*, the 'near adjacent', the 'equal-odds rule', the benefits of cognitive/ideological diversity (and lack of benefits of certain other kinds of diversity), the correlation with intelligence and personality traits like Openness...

As opposed to OP. Which adduces so little evidence for the claim about reading obituaries that a rando like me could actually write a more persuasive argument for the benefits of reading obituaries (because I at least wrote one thing tenuously inspired by reading an obituary the other month: https://gwern.net/traffic-lights ).

Even the most shameless periodical usually tries for at least 3 anecdotes, no matter how dubious and strained, before declaring it the hot new trend or It Is Known fact.

* One of Sawyer's research topics, as it happens.

Re:Read the Obits by kenjackson on Sunday April 27, 2025 @05:07PM (#43815135)
What was the groundbreaking creative that came out of this?
Re:Read the Obits by gwern on Monday April 28, 2025 @08:35PM (#43827578)
None. But then, that's still more than OP was able to adduce, as they provided no examples at all, neither groundbreaking nor creative. Which is my point: the bar of 'an anecdote' is so very low. You can provide a anecdote for the creative value of smelling rotten apples in a drawer (Schiller); you can provide an anecdote for the creative value of drinking 50 coffees a day (Balzac); you can provide an anecdote for countless crazy things people have done! But you can't provide an anecdote about reading obituaries?
Re:Read the Obits by pkkm on Monday April 28, 2025 @11:41AM (#43822706)
> the inefficacy of the popular forms of 'brainstorming' compared to the more painful forms that work

Interesting, what's your recommended resource for learning more about this?

Re:Read the Obits by gwern on Monday April 28, 2025 @08:52PM (#43827658)
I don't know if I'd recommend it, but checking, Sawyer's _Group Genius: The Creative Power of Collaboration_ book hits most of the points I'd cite about brainstorming in its chapter, so you could always start there.
Re:Read the Obits by pkkm on Tuesday April 29, 2025 @05:04AM (#43830190)
Thanks!
Re:Read the Obits by dingnuts on Monday April 28, 2025 @02:23PM (#43824408)
self promotion is gross, Gwern. It's obvious you are only commenting to drive more traffic and attention to your own blog or you'd be able to resist linking it.

You have been extremely insulated by your Bitcoin wealth and have an over inflated sense of self. Get a job. Get a life.

You are in fact a rando with too much time on your hands and too much to say about things you know too little about.

Re:Read the Obits by tomjakubowski on Tuesday April 29, 2025 @01:23PM (#43835477)
Interesting article, thanks. As a frequent city walker and cyclist, I also spend a lot of time thinking about why drivers run reds. It's rarely as simple as "drivers are too aggressive" or "drivers aren't paying attention", the real cause is often more complicated.

I don't know if the concept of "point of no return" is really such an obscure thing. It was part of my standard Illinois drivers education in the mid-00s. Every drive I did with the instructor he'd ask me to call it out when we approached a signal.

Re:Read the Obits by jerf on Sunday April 27, 2025 @05:32PM (#43815306)
I don't think anyone is asking for a double-blind study conducted by accredited scientists from multiple leading institutions on a sample of a quarter-million people across decades getting published on the front page of Science here.

We, since I will gladly agree with the criticism and add myself to that side, are asking for one example of the supposedly creativity-inducing action to have even perhaps tangentially produced some sort of creative insight.

As an example I would submit that the simple advice of "take a walk/shower" has much better attestation for prompting creativity than "read the obituaries". It hardly seems like a stretch to ask the author to provide even a single example of this achieving something.

Re:Read the Obits by jldugger on Sunday April 27, 2025 @10:12PM (#43816881)
It depends on how you define creativity probably, but a few scientific examples:

1. "Functional fixedness" was explored in a classic Candle Problem[1] found that high drive (ie rewards on a deadline) led to fewer subjects solving the problem.

2. Quality versus quantity. Sadly I can't find the TED talk (likely a decade ago?) that I saw about this but the basic idea: give subjects some kind of design problem (paper airplanes, egg drop, bridge building) and a metric measure them by. Then split them into two groups; one you measure on how many they build and the other on how well their final product is. I think there may have been some intermediate evaluation step as well, wish I could find the original research. Paradoxically, the quantity group wins on quality scores. Lesson being not to focus on perfecting your first solution.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Candle_problem