Re:Wikipedia’s nonprofit status questioned by D.C. U.S. atto...
by 20after4 on Saturday April 26, 2025 @07:27AM
(#43802662)
I think the "deletionist" tendency is one of the biggest problems with Wikipedia. At least it's the main thing that prevents me from making significant contributions. I say tendency, but maybe it really is more of a crusade. Deletion and rejection definitely seem to be the default "predisposition." I've seen a lot of examples of apparently well meaning contributors being pushed away by the need to establish "notability" for a subject and the expectation that all information must be referenced to a fairly limited number of approved reliable sources. These are norms which have been built over a long period of time so it would be incredibly difficult to change them now.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Wikipedia’s nonprofit status questioned by D.C. U.S. atto...
by potato3732842 on Saturday April 26, 2025 @08:34AM
(#43803043)
Exactly. It makes it basically impossible to get niche industry/trade information and history onto wikipedia unless it was so newsworthy it's covered everywhere.
Re:Wikipedia’s nonprofit status questioned by D.C. U.S. atto...
by kurtreed2 on Saturday April 26, 2025 @12:18PM
(#43804925)
Yet when I (or others) are trying to raise the issue on certain Reddit communities in addition to Lemmy people there still prefer to bury their heads in the sand. Often they'll simply resort to personal attacks and so on just to avoid facing the fact that Wikipedia is not as infalliable as they think at all.
Example:
Re:Wikipedia’s nonprofit status questioned by D.C. U.S. atto...
by Animats on Saturday April 26, 2025 @03:34PM
(#43806435)
That's a feature. Each article requires future attention and adds load.
Most of the important articles were in the first 100,000.
Re:Wikipedia’s nonprofit status questioned by D.C. U.S. atto...
by johnnyanmac on Saturday April 26, 2025 @05:50PM
(#43807514)
If that's the intention, fine. But don't be surprised when no one but the most committed politicians want to bother trying to contribute to the project.
Re:Wikipedia’s nonprofit status questioned by D.C. U.S. atto...
by 20after4 on Monday April 28, 2025 @01:56AM
(#43818063)
I think the ongoing hosting cost of any given article is incredibly close to zero with the exception of a very tiny fraction of popular articles. The popular ones obviously deserve to be there as evidenced by their popularity alone. Maybe there is something I'm not taking into account but I have a hard time seeing the meaningful cost of some obscure wiki page merely existing.
Re:Wikipedia’s nonprofit status questioned by D.C. U.S. atto...
by sedev on Monday April 28, 2025 @01:18PM
(#43823762)
> Maybe there is something I'm not taking into account but I have a hard time seeing the meaningful cost of some obscure wiki page merely existing.
The thing you're not taking into account is that every article that exists takes up some amount of editor time, which is why it's good when more people participate in Wikipedia. You are correct that the server/bandwidth cost of almost all articles rounds off to zero. That leaves just the cost in "an actual human looked at this and okayed it," which has different scaling characteristics.