To me, that new 'blue pill' one is better, more subdued, and the 'g' is very legible. Before that that was just a patchwork of colors and the 'g' was unreadable on a white background (i.e Chrome's own location field). The original entry by André Resende was much, much better than the messy one they used since 2009. The capital G was nice.
[1] http://googleblog.blogspot.com/2009/01/googles-new-favicon.h...