News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by Gabriel54 on Friday April 25, 2025 @01:44PM (#43796507)
What is the purpose of laws if they are willfully ignored? Where do you draw the line? If the police don't care about someone's immigration status, why should they care about who broke into your car?
Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by gortok on Friday April 25, 2025 @01:53PM (#43796614)
This over-simplifies our federal system to the point of uselessness.

The Federal Government is responsible for immigration. It's their job to set policies and adjudicate immigration issues.

Local and State Law Enforcement are not responsible for -- and indeed it is outside of their powers to enforce immigration laws.

Supreme Court precedent is that states cannot be compelled by Congress to enforce Immigration law (see: Printz v. United States).

So, what you have in this situation are the fact that States and the Federal Government have opposing interests: The States need to be able to enforce their laws without their people feeling like they can't tell the police when there's a crime, and the current federal policy is to deport all undocumented immigrants, no matter why they're here or whether they are allowed to be here while their status is adjudicated.

Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by Gabriel54 on Friday April 25, 2025 @02:02PM (#43796718)
> Supreme Court precedent is that states cannot be compelled by Congress to enforce Immigration law (see: Printz v. United States).

So the supreme court struck a reasonable compromise between federal and state interests. I am not a lawyer, but I am certain that this precedent does not give states the right to actively obstruct federal agents from doing their job, that is, to enforce federal immigration law.

Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by rolph on Friday April 25, 2025 @02:20PM (#43796933)
the feds also have no right to arbitrarily obstruct court in session, they have to seek administrative recess, they cant just barge in and start belching commands, they dont have that authority.
Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by Gabriel54 on Friday April 25, 2025 @03:00PM (#43797377)
The agents in this case did no such thing. As far as I am aware this has not happened anywhere.
Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by rolph on Friday April 25, 2025 @03:11PM (#43797492)
thats right they did no such thing, presumibly they sought recess from a chief justice, and by the time they came back, the person of concern was gone.

had they realized they were likely to walk into the middle of procedings, the first stop should have been authorization to intercede.

Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by hypeatei on Friday April 25, 2025 @02:16PM (#43796879)
> does not give states the right to actively obstruct federal agents

Who said they had that right and when did this happen?

Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by Gabriel54 on Friday April 25, 2025 @02:27PM (#43797013)
The warrant of the judge's arrest strongly suggests that she did not think it was appropriate for ICE to arrest Ruiz and took actions to prevent it from happening.
Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by sarlalian on Friday April 25, 2025 @03:17PM (#43797576)
She probably didn't think it was appropriate for ICE to arrest Ruiz at the courthouse. If going to court for a case against you becomes a good way to get deported, guess what people aren't going to do. We don't have the resources to keep everyone who has a case against them in jail, so we release people on the promise that they will show up for court. If it's dangerous to their freedom and living status to show up to court, they won't.
Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by thuanao on Friday April 25, 2025 @03:20PM (#43797608)
Considering the constitution only enumerates the power of naturalization (NOT residency) to Federal government, there is no clear power granted to Feds for things like residency visas.

Controlling the border from foreign enemies is a far cry from the Federal government asserting the right to determine who gets to simply live and work within the states.

The Supreme Court makes a mockery of 10th amendment on so many issues, whether it's drugs, healthcare, immigration, gun control...

Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by dragonwriter on Friday April 25, 2025 @02:14PM (#43796854)
> Supreme Court precedent is that states cannot be compelled by Congress to enforce Immigration law

Not just immigration law but federal law generally. It's funny that this never reached the point of beign a decision rule in a case and thus binding precedent until the 1990s, as you see it in dicta in Supreme Court cases decided on other bases back to shortly before the Civil War (specifically, in cases around the Fugitive Slave Laws.)

Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by Gabriel54 on Friday April 25, 2025 @02:19PM (#43796925)
Might it be because the federal government simply did not need to exercise much authority over the states? As a non-expert I am curious. I am continually amazed by how much authority is delegated to the states and local jurisdictions in the United States (e.g. matters of marriage, property, voting, etc.). As I understand even citizenship was handled by local courts up until very recently.
Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by dragonwriter on Friday April 25, 2025 @02:41PM (#43797146)
> Might it be because the federal government simply did not need to exercise much authority over the states?

Yeah, it is absolutely because the federal government was simply not trying to commandeer state authorities to enforce federal law; the interesting part (to me) is that the courts were anticipating the problem well before it materialized.

Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by mmanfrin on Friday April 25, 2025 @01:54PM (#43796627)
> What is the purpose of laws if they are willfully ignored?

Nearly every liberty we take for granted was at one point against the law or gained through willful lawbreaking. A healthy society should be tolerant of some bending of the rules.

Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by Gabriel54 on Friday April 25, 2025 @02:08PM (#43796792)
I agree with you. A quick search suggests that there are 11 million undocumented people in the United States, or about 3% of the population. A healthy society does not harbor 11 million people without documentation so they can be exploited by employers for cheap labor, not given proper health care and labor rights.
Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by Me1000 on Friday April 25, 2025 @02:16PM (#43796886)
Yet it's interesting how we put the blame and punishment on the people being taken advantage of, and not the employers who are exploiting them. If both parties are breaking the law shouldn't we at the very least ensure that the business owner who is exploiting any number of workers is held to the same standard as an undocumented person whose only crime was not having the proper paperwork?
Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by Gabriel54 on Friday April 25, 2025 @02:24PM (#43796987)
I don't blame them. If I were them, I would do the same thing. However, as someone with the ability to vote and influence (to a very small degree) public policy, I would prefer we move toward a system in which strong labor rights exist in this country, and this is simply impossible in an environment in which employers are free to hire labor off the books for "pennies". To be clear, I think both political parties in the US are terrible, and all of this debate serves the interests of the employers that benefit from this situation.
Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by ivape on Friday April 25, 2025 @06:16PM (#43799013)
Because it would hurt our little elitist exceptionalist hearts if we gave an H1B to a construction worker. There are low wage industries that could use such a program, but our little hearts can't take it because "its not the best and brightest".
Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by nemomarx on Friday April 25, 2025 @02:16PM (#43796877)
Right - more risk of deportations pushes them under ground and allows easier exploitation, like employers who can hold this status over their head.

People who have productively worked in the country and either paid taxes or contribute to the economy for some years should be offered pathways to naturalization or at least work visas and real legal protection.

Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by godelski on Friday April 25, 2025 @02:58PM (#43797357)
Is the number really that crazy if we consider the context?

- America is a land of opportunities. It is BY FAR the country with the largest number of legal immigrants[0]. There are ~51M in the US and the second is Germany with ~16M. I think it makes sense that given the extremely high demand to come to the US, it is unsurprising that many do so illegally. Especially when the costs of staying in your own country are so high.

- How would you even go about documenting them, determining status, and then following due process[1]. Tricky situation. It's does not only create a dystopian authoritarian hellscape to constantly check everyone's status, but it is also really expensive to do so! Random stops interfere with average citizens and violates our constitutional rights. Rights created explicitly because the people founding this country were experienced with such situations...

I mean I also agree with your point that they are being exploited and that there's been this silent quid pro quo (even if one party is getting the shit end of the deal). But also I think people really need to consider what it actually takes to get the things they want. Certainly we can do better and certainly we shouldn't exploit them. But importantly, which is more important: the rights of a citizen or punishing illegal immigrants? There has to be a balance because these are coupled. For one, I'm with Jefferson, I'd rather a hundred guilty men go free than a single innocent be stripped of their freedom. You can't pick and choose. The rules have to apply to everyone or they apply to no one. There are always costs, and the most deadly costs are those that are hard to see.

[0] https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/immigrati...

[1] I cannot stress enough how critical due process is. If we aren't going to have due process, then we don't have any laws. Full stop. If we don't have due process, then the only law is your second amendment right, and that's not what anyone wants.

Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by godelski on Friday April 25, 2025 @02:45PM (#43797195)

  > A healthy society should be tolerant of some bending of the rules.
No rule can be so well written that it covers all possible exceptions. Programmers of all people should be abundantly aware of this fact. We deal with it every single day. But I do mean fact, it is mathematically rigorous.

So even without a direct expansion of rights and the natural progression of societies to change over time, we have to at minimum recognize that there is a distinction between "what the rule says" and "what the intended rule is". This is like alignment 101.

Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by dbspin on Friday April 25, 2025 @01:46PM (#43796542)
The line is prosecution policy. There are thousands of laws on the books that are never enforced, particularly in the United States. Given the inhuman and grossly illegal deportation without due process of thousands of people by the Trump administration - to an extrajudicial torture prison no less - many means of resisting the kidnap of people (citizens or non) are reasonable).
Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by petre on Friday April 25, 2025 @02:14PM (#43796850)
I hope Trump ends up in prison, that's all I can say.

Arguably South Korea has better democracy, because Yoon Suk Yeol is probably going to prison for insurrection.

Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by ClumsyPilot on Friday April 25, 2025 @02:07PM (#43796776)
I am still waiting for a “corporations are people” to get death penalty
Re:FBI arrests Wisconsin judge on charges of obstructing imm... by crote on Friday April 25, 2025 @06:49PM (#43799219)
Should a serial killer go unpunished because its sole witness would face lifetime imprisonment for jaywalking if they were to testify? Do you believe gangs should roam free due to a lack of evidence, or would it be better if they could be rolled up by offering a too-sweet-to-ignore plea deal to a snitch?

Laws are are already routinely being ignored. There's a massive amount of discretionary choice space for law enforcement and prosecution. It's not as black-and-white as you're making it sound.