Re:Three Fundamental Flaws of SIMD ISAs (2023)
by ack_complete on Friday April 25, 2025 @03:58PM
(#43797946)
Sure, but any core-wide downclocking effect at all is annoying for autovectorization, since a small local win easily turns into a global loss. Which is why compilers have "prefer vector width" tuning parameters so autovec can be tuned down to avoid 512-bit or even 256-bit ops.
This is also the same reason that having AVX-512 only on the P-cores wouldn't have worked, even with thread director support. It would only take one small routine in a common location to push most threads off the P-cores.
I'm of the opinion that Intel's hybrid P/E-arch has been mostly useless anyway and only good for winning benchmarks. My current CPU has a 6P4E configuration and the scheduler hardly uses the E-cores at all unless forced, plus performance was better and more stable with the E-cores disabled.
I'm not sure why OS kernels couldn't have become partners in CPU capability queries (where a program starting execution could request a CPU core with 'X' such as AVX-512F, for example) -- but without that the whole P-core/E-core hybrid concept was DOA for capabilities which were not least-common denominators. If I had to guess, marketing got ahead of engineering and testing on that one.