News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mistaking Mary Magdalene by jfengel on Thursday April 24, 2025 @08:06PM (#43788856)
There are at least five different Mary's in the Gospels. She was not the prostitute, but the prostitute was also a Mary.

It is, as you say, a misogynist way to dismiss the many women who were important during Jesus' ministry and during the founding of the early gentile Churches. But the book sure doesn't make it easy to keep em straight.

Re:Mistaking Mary Magdalene by shampto3 on Thursday April 24, 2025 @09:02PM (#43789200)
There is no prostitute called Mary in the Gospels. There was a conflation of three women:

- Mary Magdalene who had 7 devils cast out of her

- Mary of Bethany who anointed Christ with oil close to his crucifixion

- Unnamed woman who anointed Christ with oil and tears in the home of Simon

Not only are these three woman separate and distinct, none of them are even explicitly called out as prostitutes. So they both conflated their stories and assumed what the sin was.

Other Marys in the Gospels:

- Mary the mother of Christ

- Mary the mother of James

- Mary of Clopas

Re:Mistaking Mary Magdalene by o11c on Thursday April 24, 2025 @11:41PM (#43789904)
And if anyone is like me and thinking "wait, there are more Marys than that", the above comment specifies "in the gospels".

Mary mother of [John] Mark is in Acts, and Mary of Rome is in Romans.

It's generally assumed that "the other Mary" is one of the above. It is widely, but not universally, assumed that the two "Mary and Martha" stories refer to the same people. Some traditions say that Salome was yet another Mary, but this seems poorly founded.

Re:Mistaking Mary Magdalene by amanaplanacanal on Friday April 25, 2025 @06:19AM (#43792055)
How do we know those are the different women though?
Re:Mistaking Mary Magdalene by watwut on Friday April 25, 2025 @10:11AM (#43793762)
By reading with comprehension.
Re:Mistaking Mary Magdalene by amanaplanacanal on Friday April 25, 2025 @11:06AM (#43794331)
Not a helpful response. There are scholars that argue that Mary Magdalen and Mary of Bethany are the same person, which was the impetus for my question.
Re:Mistaking Mary Magdalene by shampto3 on Friday April 25, 2025 @01:42PM (#43796481)
We of course can't know for sure, but I personally err on the side of caution and keep these women as separate individuals. The stories are distinct enough that in my opinion they should be considered unique events and different people.
Re:Mistaking Mary Magdalene by Spooky23 on Thursday April 24, 2025 @10:32PM (#43789598)
Poole Gregory gave an influential sermon that conflated several women featured in the Bible incorrectly. That carried on for a millennia for various reasons.
Re:Mistaking Mary Magdalene by milesrout on Friday April 25, 2025 @04:57AM (#43791645)
How is it misogynistic for more than one woman to have the same name? They aren't made up characters that people decided to all call Mary in some fit of misogyny.
Re:Mistaking Mary Magdalene by shadowgovt on Friday April 25, 2025 @11:19AM (#43794498)
Given that the books were written at least 40 years after the described events, how do we know they aren't made-up characters (or pastiches of real individuals)?

Perhaps 'Mary' was a stand-in name for "Woman nobody thought to write down the name of," like "Karen" is a stand-in name today.

Re:Mistaking Mary Magdalene by etse on Saturday April 26, 2025 @12:48AM (#43801030)
Interesting idea, but questionable scholarship.