Re:Why Folders are holding back hassle-free File Management ...
by joe_the_user on Monday August 13, 2012 @03:59PM
(#4377811)
One way to deal with ambiguous tags is to use aliases and related-to indicators.
But I agree with you that a system can't discard the file hierarchy without discarding important qualities many people need.
Re:Why Folders are holding back hassle-free File Management ...
by drharris on Monday August 13, 2012 @04:05PM
(#4377835)
That's of course a good point. However, one of the things the tagging proponents claim is that tagging reduces the effort of taxonomy. Having to manage aliases and tag links would then negate any such benefit, and might even be much more time consuming.
Now, were we to talk about some standard of tagging that has link relationships baked in, we might be talking. But then we sacrifice customization.
I think the true future is in a hybrid. Improve the metadata on a file (Windows is making giant leaps in this territory), improve file search indexing and capabilities, and retain a hierarchy. This allows ease of both searching and browsing, and is not any different from what we're doing today (no retraining Grandma).