Next step is disconnecting from "usage" (right now, plans are based on # of employees using the software, all plans have the same features) and moving towards plans based on the goals of the business: Do they need reporting? Are they comfortable being a solo freelancer working from Starbucks, or is the customer (or wants to look like) a big agency that needs a lot more flexibility?
We've found that increased usage is not what differentiates our users (no one hits the imposed limits on their plans). So we're switching to plans that users should be able to read and immediately identify themselves with (Solo, Consultant, Agency)
Would love to chat with you about your thoughts and results if you're interested.
I hereby declare this to be the correct technical term for it. The guys in marketing may be calling it something else, but I don't think you'll find a more succinct description of the strategy.
The guys in marketing may be calling it something else...
I have a suspicion the marketing guys might come up with that terminology as well (sorry I couldn't resist a little off topic inside baseball)The original page prominently says: "Sign up for a free trial" and gets a 6.9% conversion from visitor to trial user.
The new page unprominently says: "Money back guarantee" and "Free Sign Up" in the top right corner. Conversion is 5.2%, which is almost the same considering the scope of the change, even though there was much less use of the word "Free".
This is surprising in itself.
I'm also curious about how the next stage of the funnel is converting users from the trial to entering their credit cards.
Also you say that credit card signup is not mandatory. When does the CC enter the picture? Does the service wait a while (e.g. one month ) and ask you to enter you credit card? How does this compare to taking a credit-card upfront and offering a one-month money-back guarantee?
I work in the e-commerce "ecosystem". What's your opinion about offering all software functionality for free, but charge for support and other side services like "product catalog management", "product image treatment", "e-mail marketing campaigns management" etc? Do you think customers may like the idea?
These very desirable business customers will run screaming from the impending trainwreck of a company which is proposing a) tie your business at the hip to ours and b) we could fold at any stiff breeze.
Which techniques?
Market segmentation and pricing by features? Sure, absolutely. Some people value a certain service more than other people depending on their circumstances, just as some businesses do.
Doubling/trebling your prices overnight and hoping you'll get a similar number of customers all paying several times as much? ROFLOLWAT. These customers are spending their own money, and not only will many of them take their business elsewhere if you try to charge insulting prices, they'll tell all their friends that your service is a rip-off, too.
Obviously it's not really as simple as that. For example, a lot of businesses pitch their prices far lower than market value would support at first. In those cases, increasing the prices to something higher but still reasonable is fine and often quite lucrative.
But you're absolutely right that advice that holds for B2B environments doesn't necessarily work the same way in a B2C context. The starting point and assumptions simply aren't the same.
Oh, and thanks for writing this, there's some really useful information here.
Can I give you a suggestion that's halfway there? There's no reason that your /pricing page has to be the only channel anywhere for getting signups. You might have a particular recommendation specific to a particular audience and give that particular audience just a single option. For example, when I write drip marketing campaigns, I often pitch the #3 out of 4 plan semi-exclusively, and send folks to pages which plug it and only it. (If you want to hear more about drip marketing get on my email list. August will be a fun month for you. If you don't want to hear about email marketing optimization my email list is a very bad place to be for the next couple of weeks.)
There's a semi-related issue where talking in a particular way can make you seem like The Other to someone, and you don't want to do that, but I doubt the person with purchasing authority is so scared of math that this qualifies. (I might avoid putting a D&D joke on that page, where I would totally do that when talking directly to a geeky audience, if that fits the company culture.)
This would tend to suggest not pricing backups by weight at all because, crucially, businesses do not value data by weight. 8 GB of bingo cards: doesn't matter if they get rm -rf'ed, I can regenerate them trivially. 200kb gzipped of Appointment Reminder database backups: that literally represents more than half my net worth. The production database for a large enterprise customer? That might trivially be worth $20k+ per month, totally no-brainer, regardless of size.
My most specific recommendation: if the pricing page includes "picodollars", it really shouldn't. (Much love for Tarsnap but darn it I'm right.)
I knew that was coming as soon as I read the question. :-)
I think I understand your point that you're not interested in having the type of customer who would be scared away by 'picodollars' (as opposed to finding it amusing) but you should at least test it out and get the numbers to verify your hypothesis right?
(As a bonus, if you're right, you get to shove it in the faces of everyone else. If you're wrong - well congratulations - you just increased sales)
Unless you're doing this more as a principled stand (which is fine I guess).
I respect that everyone has their own motivations for doing things and that economic optimality is not the be-all-end-all. Colin can run Tarsnap as an underpriced public utility if he wants to. But, Scout's honor, it is underpriced. The pricing model actively discourages large, savvy customers whose lives and businesses would benefit from switching to Tarsnap in favor of pathological bottom-feeders who gain no significant benefit from Tarsnap. My personal opinion is, in addition to costing Colin money, this moots the impact that his (extraordinarily impressive) engineering achievement could otherwise be providing to the world.
This is a very awkward conversion for me, so I'm going to refrain from the unsolicited advice for at least a few months until picodollars just make me snap again.
Colin "gets away" with "picodollar pricing" because he is deliberately segmenting away most of his customer base. I am not entirely sure why he is doing that, but he has made a strategic decision in the short term to make less money in order to build his service up more slowly and, I presume, carefully. He exclusively wants the kind of customers who will not be annoyed with this annoying price model; in other words, the kind of customer that has time to reason through the idiosyncratic pricing scheme of a new backup service.
Unless slowing the growth of your own service is one of your goals, do not mistake what Colin is doing here with a pricing strategy that works in the general case.
In any case I always thought that Colin could get out of the low price quicksand by launching an entirely rebranded service with updated pricing based on value to customer, etc. sure, keep the original guys around too. Throw in some perks on the "new" service that are attractive to enterprise customers. It's not every day you have a product of this quality and (potential) customers willing to pay so much.
Assuming the goal is to have only technically sophisticated users who want to use the most durable data store known to man (S3) and have a rock solid & secure backup solution, the pricing structure being 3-6 times that of s3 pricing is a great value on all sides.
actually: colin, could you tell us perhaps what the total monthly storage and or bandwidth volume is? I don't think that if has ever been stated on the internet :)
caveat: i've been playing with tarsnap on/off since it was first launched, and now that i'm doing my own wee startup, i'm using it quite seriously and religiously to backup my working directories. Love it. (however much i email the tarsnap user list with some confusion thats easy to sort out every time i've resumed using tarsnap after some hiatus :) )
Speaking of which: if it isn't transparently obvious by now, I really, really like getting feedback about how my advice worked out. If you ever implement a suggestion from me (particularly with an A/B test), please, drop me an email. Even if the result was "Well, that was sure an epic failure", because negative confirmation is useful, too. (If you want to share results I can write up for the blog, I appreciate that, too, but I'd be just as pleased with a "Keep this under your hat but we did a first-experience tour and, yikes, engagement +20%.")