Re:Why Folders are holding back hassle-free File Management ...
by maxerickson on Monday August 13, 2012 @12:22PM
(#4376632)
There's not really any need to address it specially. Tags only get added to the extent that users care, so mismatches are a problem of abundance, and to the extent tags are meaningful/accurate, they facilitate editing to personal preference.
I'm sure that successful file managers will also have some degree of fuzzy matching. But tags are still useful, even if we never realize the RDF dream of a perfect global ontology.
Re:Why Folders are holding back hassle-free File Management ...
by secabeen on Monday August 13, 2012 @12:45PM
(#4376744)
Do they, though? I'm not very good at remembering which tags I use, and once you have hundreds of documents sharing a single tag, if you mis-tag a new file, you may never find it again.
Folders make using previous organizational decisions easier than creating a new organization. Incentivizing that behavior is a net win.
Re:Why Folders are holding back hassle-free File Management ...
by maxerickson on Monday August 13, 2012 @12:53PM
(#4376791)
Do what what?
I'm not all gaga over tags, keeping 'primary organizational tags' around makes lots of sense to me. We can even keep on calling them folders. My point is that you really have to construct a silly, user-hostile system for a tagging capability to actually make things worse than no tagging.
Do you have any plans for how to address this?