Re:Pipelining might be my favorite programming language feature
by hinkley on Monday April 21, 2025 @01:44PM
(#43754497)
The pipe operator relies on the first argument being the subject of the operation. A lot of languages have the arguments in a different order, and OO languages sometimes use function chaining to get a similar result.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Pipelining might be my favorite programming language feature
by Terr_ on Monday April 21, 2025 @02:15PM
(#43754809)
IIRC the usual workaround in Elixir involves be small lambda that rearranges things:
"World"
|> then(&concat("Hello ", &1))
I imagine a shorter syntax could someday be possible, where some special placeholder expression could be used, ex: "World"
|> concat("Hello ", &1)
However that creates a new problem: If the implicit-first-argument form is still permitted (foo() instead of foo(&1)) then it becomes confusing which function-arity is being called. A human could easily fail to notice the absence or presence of the special placeholder on some lines, and invoke the wrong thing.
Re:Pipelining might be my favorite programming language feature
by hinkley on Monday April 21, 2025 @03:49PM
(#43755730)
Yeah I really hate that syntax and I can’t even explain why so I kind of blot it out, but you’re right.
My dislike does improve my test coverage though, since I tend to pop out a real method instead.
Re:Pipelining might be my favorite programming language feature
by freehorse on Monday April 21, 2025 @07:07PM
(#43757492)
Yeah, R (tidyverse) has `.` as such a placeholder. It is useful but indeed I find the syntax off, though I find the syntax off even without it, anyway. I would rather define pipes as compositions of functions, which are pretty unambiguous in terms of what arguments they get, and then apply these to whatever i want.
Re:Pipelining might be my favorite programming language feature
by agent281 on Monday April 21, 2025 @09:22PM
(#43758259)
Last time I checked (2020) there were already a few rejected proposals to shorten the syntax for this. It seemed like they were pretty exasperated by them at the time.
Re:Pipelining might be my favorite programming language feature
by BoingBoomTschak on Monday April 21, 2025 @04:17PM
(#43756012)