Well, I have been in big companies where it takes a lot of time for the legal department to check those things. Not because it's fundamentally hard, but because the queue of things they have to do is pretty big.
> They thank them for their "generous insights". That's not the same thing.
Sure, it's wrong. But it's not "purposely stealing without giving any credit at all" either. It feels like an engineer did that, tried to give credit and did it wrong. And now we go on and on saying how this engineer is evil.
In this case I still feel like they are more attributing incorrectly (there is a link to the original repo with a "thank you" note) than plagiarizing.
If there was no mention of the original project at all, then I could call it "accidental plagiarism".
> they mentioned the original project in the README
They thank them for their "generous insights". That's not the same thing. If I take chapters unmodified from Harry Potter and thank Rowling for her "generous insight", that's still not okay.
> Peerd is quite different from Spegel, it's not just a copy with a small patch.
Nobody said it was. It does, however, copy functions and other entire blocks of code with comments directly from Spegel without giving attribution. That is wrong. That is plagiarism.