News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by glenngillen on Monday April 21, 2025 @07:20AM (#43750640)
Hey, this sucks. Unfortunately the MIT license doesn't do much to prevent this and (I think?) their licensing transgression is they haven't kept "Copyright (c) 2024 The Spegel Authors" in the LICENSE file. I suspect if you call them out on it that'll be the remediation.

Did you manage to reach out to any of the people at MSFT you originally spoke to to ask wtf?

Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by phillebaba on Monday April 21, 2025 @07:29AM (#43750698)
Any copies of the code should include the notice according to the MIT license. I do agree that I could have used a less permissive license, and it is something that I am now considering to change.

The reality is that licenses do not mean anything unless you are actually able to enforce it. So I really do not think the license would have mattered in this case.

Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by elteto on Monday April 21, 2025 @08:53AM (#43751454)
Licenses absolutely matter, that’s the whole point of using them! Big corps will absolutely not risk being sued over infringement, it’s not worth it to them. For the litigation cost they’ll throw a couple engineers and redo your project from scratch.

Sorry it happened to you but it seems like you just picked the wrong license.

Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by throwaway277432 on Monday April 21, 2025 @07:34AM (#43750732)
It's been happening for years. They don't care.

See e.g. Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyright (1326 points, 538 comments, Dec 25, 2021) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29683471

That time their excuse was "our automation was wrong". I wonder what it'll be this time.

It will probably be fixed and they'll say sorry and so on but MS doesn't really care about this at their core.

Embrace, extend, extinguish is what works, and they know it.

Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by diggan on Monday April 21, 2025 @07:22AM (#43750650)
> Unfortunately the MIT license doesn't do much to prevent this

Seems both you and Microsoft needs to actually read through the MIT license, it isn't that long or complicated :)

> The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all copies or substantial portions of the Software.

That part is even in it's own paragraph and everything, really hard to miss for anyone who even glances at the license.

Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by gortok on Monday April 21, 2025 @07:31AM (#43750711)
Define “substantial”?

What percentage of copying is “substantial”?

That’s the problem with concisely written licenses, the legal world thrives on definitions and terms of art, and when you leave something open to interpretation you invite the probability that a nefarious (or even sufficiently amoral actor like a large corporation) actor will point to the language you use and interpret it differently.

To win any argument in a court of law you must now spend time and money to win the argument. Something an open source maintainer likely doesn’t have, and since the license doesn’t specify damages, there’s no way to even write in a penalty for failure to adhere such that a court of law would consider it under contract law, and then you have to prove damages.

At least in Virginia, each party pays their own lawyers fees, even if they win. You can only collect lawyers fees when statutes allow you to, or there has been sufficient bad faith from the other side that the court uses its own power to sanction.

Oh, and let’s say you win and somehow you are able to prove damages. Now you have to spend money to collect on the judgment. That’s money you’re not getting back.

The point here is that we’ve written software licenses as contracts that assume good faith and do not punish bad actors, when we would need to treat corporations as if they are bad actors and write licenses accordingly.

Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by dtech on Monday April 21, 2025 @07:30AM (#43750703)
So if both versions use the same MIT license, the only difference is the line parent highlighted...
Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by john_the_writer on Monday April 21, 2025 @07:33AM (#43750722)
What they likely mean is that MS says "Good luck enforcing this. Have you met our legal team?" Nothing they can't walk around, or drown you in legal fees while they smile.