News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

A comment on Goodbye, Hacker News. I'm going back to Reddit..

Re:Goodbye, Hacker News. I'm going back to Reddit. by pg on Saturday August 18, 2007 @03:54AM (#43743)
It's the final straw that we fix typos and abusive punctuation in submission titles? That seems a bit melodramatic.

I'm surprised to think anyone didn't already realize we did this. Did you really think people on news.yc had that much better spelling than reddit users?

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Goodbye, Hacker News. I'm going back to Reddit. by trekker7 on Saturday August 18, 2007 @04:10AM (#43749)
As opposed to caring about the specifics like fixing punctuation, I think that critics don't like the authority (and potential for abuse) implied by administrators messing with user submitted text, no matter in how trivial a way.

At some point users have to decide if they're willing to sacrifice a purely democratic community if it means an increase in quality. Is the point of a social news site to make a political statement, or is it find cool stuff to read?

Edit: Maybe the admins should just be 100% transparent about everything they do; document their actions in a FAQ.

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Goodbye, Hacker News. I'm going back to Reddit. by rms on Saturday August 18, 2007 @06:07AM (#43762)
Transparency makes this a non-issue. Admin actions like editing titles should automatically show up on a log page.
[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Goodbye, Hacker News. I'm going back to Reddit. by pg on Saturday August 18, 2007 @11:20AM (#43812)
You're probably right. No one complains when whole submissions are deleted as spams, presumably because you can see them if you want by turning on showdead in your profile. So maybe I'll add something to preserve original submission titles.
[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Goodbye, Hacker News. I'm going back to Reddit. by jmzachary on Saturday August 18, 2007 @09:49AM (#43782)
"Authority (and potential for abuse) implied"? Well, I guess different things upset different types of people. Why does this have to be "democratic community"? Is the "democratic community" paying the bills for the site? I'm not a PG sycophant, but I come to the defense of the site maintainers. I would rather read a sanitized and on-target news.ycombinator site than a mob-rulz reddit site. But ultimately, they serve two different purposes.

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Goodbye, Hacker News. I'm going back to Reddit. by staunch on Saturday August 18, 2007 @07:52AM (#43768)
When it comes to online forums I have no hesitation in giving up "full democracy". A benevolent dictator and his helpers is a great solution to maintaining a quality community. The way they go about doing it will simply filter out those who don't like their style. Nothing wrong with that. Not everyone is willing to deal with Linus Torvalds and his helpers either. Transparency here is optional but preferred.
[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Goodbye, Hacker News. I'm going back to Reddit. by fallintothis on Saturday August 18, 2007 @04:09AM (#43748)
"Did you really think people on news.yc had that much better spelling than reddit users?"

Sure, shatter the illusion why don't ya?

Kidding aside, I don't know why people are flipping out. One should think the editors are carefully chosen to not be power-hungry jackasses out to destroy a story's integrity. It's not even like they're editing comments. Some people are quick to jump on the drama, I suppose. I share in the same sentiment expressed here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43650

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Goodbye, Hacker News. I'm going back to Reddit. by inchforward on Saturday August 18, 2007 @04:53PM (#43882)
Why not spell-check the titles?
[ Parent | on HN ]