News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Analyzed Chord Progressions in 680k Songs by airstrike on Friday April 18, 2025 @10:38AM (#43728505)
Except music theory has a math component to it so it's arguably somewhat quantifiable and falsifiable in a way that linguistics never will be.
Re:I Analyzed Chord Progressions in 680k Songs by uoaei on Friday April 18, 2025 @05:04PM (#43731856)
This is an incredibly ignorant assertion, even for someone who has so obviously studied neither linguistics nor music theory.
Re:I Analyzed Chord Progressions in 680k Songs by airstrike on Friday April 18, 2025 @07:31PM (#43732823)
This is an incredibly ignorant retort, even for someone who has so obviously studied neither debate nor logical reasoning.
Re:I Analyzed Chord Progressions in 680k Songs by uoaei on Friday April 18, 2025 @08:37PM (#43733186)
If you had more to say on the topic at hand, you would have said it by now. I'm not interested in trying to educate someone so comfortable in promulgating assertions informed by nothing but amateur-level vibes.

We could list the logical fallacies you're displaying in the spirit of "debate and reasoning" but I have no faith this would go anywhere productive.

Report me instead of complaining about guidelines if retaliation for being exposed for your ignorance is so important to you.

Re:I Analyzed Chord Progressions in 680k Songs by airstrike on Friday April 18, 2025 @08:51PM (#43733263)
But it would be terribly wasteful to further entertain someone on the subject of music and artificial intelligence, when it is so evident they must first overcome their oblivious impertinence and emotional incompetence in order for such debate to be even moderately enjoyable to anyone else less arrogant and unhappy.

You assume my choice to not continue the conversation is because I have nothing to say, when in fact I do so because I have nothing to say to you specifically.

Re:I Analyzed Chord Progressions in 680k Songs by uoaei on Saturday April 19, 2025 @07:34PM (#43740306)
Oh good, you know big words. Next on the list is to learn the relevant big words for the things for which you claim competence. I'll wait.

PS: it's funny that your best comeback is just to imitate the critique I levied against you. You could demonstrate your "debate and reasoning" ability by crafting an actual argument, but you don't. I'm convinced that was not a cognizant choice but an act of desperation to save what's left of your ego. I've dealt with your type enough to know what you are, and after all this you will be forced to acknowledge the same... unless your ego really is strong enough to overcome your capacity for "reasoning".

Re:I Analyzed Chord Progressions in 680k Songs by Tainnor on Saturday April 19, 2025 @05:00AM (#43735163)
There is a lot of mathematics that can be used to analyse language. Phonetics is basically acoustics, phonology has things like optimality theory, for morphology you can use finite state machines, syntax uses formal grammars, statistics obviously plays a big role in certain areas, etc.

Both in the case of music and linguistics, there are people who argue (probably not wholly without merit) that looking at the mathematics too much is missing the point.

Re:I Analyzed Chord Progressions in 680k Songs by uoaei on Saturday April 19, 2025 @07:41PM (#43740342)
A refusal to acknowledge such integral parts of these systems as semantics renders that line of argument wholly irrelevant. No good faith discussion cannot be conducted without participants who already understand the meaning behind symbols.
Re:I Analyzed Chord Progressions in 680k Songs by Tainnor on Sunday April 20, 2025 @05:07AM (#43742585)
I'm afraid I don't understand your reply.
Re:I Analyzed Chord Progressions in 680k Songs by uoaei on Wednesday April 23, 2025 @03:47PM (#43775969)
It doesn't matter at all what "mathematics" you use to "analyze" music because the purpose of these modes of communication goes beyond the arbitrary sounds chosen -- what does matter is what is being represented by those sounds.

Statistics is for the analysis of systems in equilibrium. Language by definition is a non-equilibrium system.