And that you will be able to keep the expensive property with expensive costs. Plus compare if living in the expensive vs cheap place gets you more savings...
No, it does not make sense. I can see holding a property for a child, but not as retirement.
Using properties as store of value or betting on them becoming more expensive have too many externalities.
Your case for exemple is directly leading to people actually living and working in the less expensive places being displaced by retirees from the city which is very much undesirable for local life.
This is true, but it also creates vacancies in the cities. The retired have to live somewhere..
If you're in negative or reduced equity your mortgage costs can increase dramatically when you refinance. This alone can easily cripple a large % of the population and tank the consumer economy
Of course that doesn't eliminate the economic impact. It just shifts it elsewhere.
An decent case can probably be made for the government to take on such loans and offer some scheme to forgive the difference if certain criteria are met.
Forced variable rates are a scam.
It's fake savings unless you are speculating on properties.
Most people only own the place they actually live in and only resell to buy another place. A general property market crash doesn't affect the value of your house compared to other house so it's mostly neutral in this regard.
Of course people who borrowed before the crash will be in debt for longer than people who bought after but that doesn't actually change their debt situation. You might say it's unfair but well, not wanting other to be better of doesn't seem like a good reason to not solve the housing crisis.
In the end the only people who trully stand to lose are multi-owners but they are a significant part of the problem in the first place so that doesn't make me sad.